LivingDNA Ydna result

[Jana]

Im not saying its a problem. Im saying these autosomal results and pca maps dont make any sense.
There are autosomal tests that go like 1000 to 1500 years back such as MyOrigins supposedly goes back 2000 years. If he has tested then he should show obvious slavic admixture. Gedmatch calcs go even much further back, they go back thousands of years. Yet he doesnt show much signs of it if I remember correctly.
Neither dna land, not even drawing slim who is I2a1b does much.

There is a Jewish (in pink) and mediterranean/Greek (purple) cluster of I2-dinaric


But to see if I2-dinaric Albanians have that they need to do a deep subclade testing. Same with R1a, FTDNA projects are good for that.

[Voskos]

Have you received a congratulation phonecall from Rethel yet?

[Era]

Hevo's chart doesnt associate it with slavs. It's a big group. You will need to test it further for a more specific clade.

[Lek]

Hevo's chart doesnt associate it with slavs. It's a big group. You will need to test it further for a more specific clade.

Thats what i was thinking too. That picture didnt tell me much.

[Karol Klačansky]

It doesn't make him Slavic or any less Albanian, so don't see problem with it.

Sure it does. He's descended from some Slavic dude

Sent from my KIW-L21 using Tapatalk

[Dibran]

Sure it does. He's descended from some Slavic dude

Sent from my KIW-L21 using Tapatalk

All studies on it associate it with Corded Ware and the Kurgans. It's also older than Proto Slavic branches. So it can't be Slavic when Proto Slavic among Scandinavian clades descend from it.

[Kelmendasi]

I have seen some sources claim that it's of Corded ware and later on Germanic origin

[Kelmendasi]

"The Germanic branch

The first major expansion of R1a took place with the westward propagation of the Corded Ware (or Battle Axe) culture (2800-1800 BCE) from the northern forest-steppe in the Yamna homeland. This was the first wave of R1a into Europe, the one that brought the Z283 subclade to Germany and the Netherlands, and Z284 to Scandinavia. The Corded Ware R1a people would have mixed with the pre-Germanic I1 and I2 aborigines, which resulted in the first Indo-European culture in Germany and Scandinavia, although that culture could not be considered Proto-Germanic - it was simply Proto-Indo-European at that stage, or perhaps or Proto-Balto-Slavic."

[Kelmendasi]

Judging by the R1a project on Ftdna, Z283 is found in Germanic countries, Slavic countries and even in some MENA countries

[Lek]

Sure it does. He's descended from some Slavic dude

Sent from my KIW-L21 using Tapatalk

Nice logic. Proto Albanians were indo europeans, they absorbed non-IE people, going by your logic those people are not Albanians..

What about all the I2a and I1.. it wasnt originially slavic or about all the EV13 and R1b in south slavs which is obviously from vlachs and Albanians. I gotplentyof slavicized Serbs whos paternal ancestors were Albanians which exceeds by far the slavic ancestry in Albs

But when an Albanian tests a non Albanian ydna like slavic , you all get excited lol.. there was an Albanian recently tested i2a1b.. both are still minorities in the hundreds of Albanians tested. There are by far more south slavs with ev13 etc