Differences between Men and Women are Vastly Exaggerated

[Era]

Published on August 7, 2017




If you’ve read the recent memo by a Silicon Valley engineer about diversity, you probably had a strong emotional reaction.

It’s always precarious to make claims about how one half of the population differs from the other half—especially on something as complicated as technical skills and interests. But I think it’s a travesty when discussions about data devolve into name-calling and threats. As a social scientist, I prefer to look at the evidence.

The gold standard is a meta-analysis: a study of studies, correcting for biases in particular samples and measures. Here’s what meta-analyses tell us about gender differences:

1. When it comes to abilities, attitudes, and actions, sex differences are few and small.

Across 128 domains of the mind and behavior, “78% of gender differences are small or close to zero.” A recent addition to that list is leadership, where men feel more confident but women are rated as more competent.

There are only a handful of areas with large sex differences: men are physically stronger and more physically aggressive, masturbate more, and are more positive on casual sex. So you can make a case for having more men than women… if you’re fielding a sports team or collecting semen.

2. In the U.S., boys aren’t better at math than girls.

Across nearly 4,000 studies, the average gender gap in math achievement is not statistically different from zero. The two sexes have very similar variances, with men showing slightly more variability. And there are just as many cases where girls outperform boys in math as vice-versa:



3. Where male advantages in math ability exist, they’re heavily influenced by cultural biases.

Girls do as well as boys—or slightly better—in math in elementary, but boys have an edge by high school. Male advantages are more likely to exist in countries that lack gender equity in school enrollment, women in research jobs, and women in parliament—and that have stereotypes associating science with males.

If you don’t see bias there, try this: when teachers know students’ names, boys do better on math tests. Yet when grading is anonymous, girls do better on math tests. And before a math test, reminding college students of their gender leads girls to perform 43% worse than boys. But if you just call it a problem-solving test, the gender gap in performance disappears.

Biases affect men too. Women are stereotyped as more empathetic, and they do score higher than men when you test the ability to read other people’s thoughts and feelings. But if you don’t introduce it as an empathy test, the gender gap vanishes.

4. There are sex differences in interests, but they’re not biologically determined.

The data on occupational interests do reveal strong male preferences for working with things and strong female preferences for working with people. But they also reveal that men and women are equally interested in working with data.

So why are there so many more male than female engineers? Because women have systematically been discouraged from working with computers. Look at trends in college majors: since the 1980s, the proportion of female majors has gone up in science and medicine and law, but down in computer science.



We know that interests are highly malleable. Female students become significantly more interested in science careers after having a teacher who discusses the problem of underrepresentation. And at Harvey Mudd College, computer science majors were around 10% women a decade ago. Today they’re 55%.

It’s time to stop making mountains out of molehills. If men are from Mars, it looks like women are too.

***

Adam Grant is an organizational psychologist, Wharton’s top-rated professor, and a New York Times bestselling author who shares insights every month in GRANTED

[Pennywise]

Gender is a social construct. Biology is bullshit.

[War Chef]

Well first off, we both experience the human condition (perfect balance of pleasure & pain) so that is the basis of any similarities I see between male & female. The technical details to me don't really matter.


As for the rest, some good points.

I'd like to add, in a certain African hunter-gather tribe the women actually pull in more food by pound by (picking berries, foraging for nuts etc.) than males, who average 1 gazelle per week. So something to think about.

Also, I never understood why women are so enthusiastic about proving their equality to the point of obsession. To care this much about it must secretly say you are insecure to go out of your way to prove that you're just as capable as any guy.

You don't see guys trying to argue "we're just as good as women" because they're secure & it's already established.

[MissMischief]

Some believe that behavioural differences between men and women are mostly the result of society's expectations/cultural influences, while others claim that sex differences are hard-wired at birth.

Actually, I think this is sort of sidestepping the real issue. Suppose someone proved there was a lot of biological determinism in, say, the numbers of male vs. female engineers. Well so what? The really important thing is not to use that (or even the suspicion of it) as a reason for discouraging anyone from undertaking a career. It really wouldn't matter if there was some part of the brain, usually absent from women, which was connected with enjoying engineering-type activities.

The thing is that nobody should ever hear the words "you should not pursue that career because men/women are not biologically fitted for it." Because such results only apply on average - they cannot, and should not, be turned around and used to restrict individuals.

[Miekka]

New study examines thousands of brains from two decades of research to reveal differences between male and female brain structure.

Professor Suckling added: “The sex differences in the limbic system include areas often implicated in psychiatric conditions with biased sex ratios such as autism, schizophrenia, and depression. This new study may therefore help us understand not just typical sex differences but also sex-linked psychiatric conditions...