Citizenship and Y-DNA

[Rethel]

Should genetics be taken into consideration for people who apply for citizenship?

Does it make any sense to limit citizenship approvals to certain Y-DNA groups/subgroups?

Yes, IE countries should give full citizenship only to IEs (R1).

For example we could limit our country (Bosnia) not to accept J1 or C people as potential citizens by law while
we could make citizenship easily obtainable to I2a1-Din people.

Does that makes any sense?

No, becasue Bośnia is IE country, so it would be the stupidest thing which they could do.

But you have a like for a good thread.

[DarknessWin]

Again this story,
HAPLOGROUP HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH PHENOTYPE

[DarknessWin]

Yes, IE countries should give full citizenship only to IEs (R1).



No, becasue Bośnia is IE country, so it would be the stupidest thing which they could do.

But you have a like for a good thread.

Ok lets start this from Poland,
Give citizenship to Afgans,Pakistanis and Indians
all of them are R1a
LOL

[Rethel]

Again this story,
HAPLOGROUP HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH PHENOTYPE

Again the same story: noone was saying this but you are fighting fictional problems.

[Rethel]

Ok lets start this from Poland,
Give citizenship to Afgans,Pakistanis and Indians
all of them are R1a
LOL

Who said that ALL R1 should get it?
It was saying only about it as sine qua non. Other things can be taken unto account also.
I do not see the reason why pagans should be allowed to settle here at all, even if they are R1.
If they would want to, they should make some work - for example be baptized at the beginning.

[Dandelion]

In Poland a caste system should be set in place. R1a at the top of the pyramid, followed by R1b. All the rest would be below them.

Families of other Y-haplogroups could only climb upward the social ladder by having their daughter marry an R1 man.

[Danaan]

Who said that ALL R1 should get it?
It was saying only about it as sine qua non. Other things can be taken unto account also.
I do not see the reason why pagans should be allowed to settle here at all, even if they are R1.
If they would want to, they should make some work - for example be baptized at the beginning.

We have an agreement then.

Poland will give citizenship rights to all Central & South Asian R1 Christians.

[Finnish Swede]

Yes, IE countries should give full citizenship only to IEs (R1).

So I1 is not Indo European? I knew that it's not ''Aryan''.

If so, then how about same with European countries like Sweden? There I1 is most common Y-haplogroup.

[DarknessWin]

Who said that ALL R1 should get it?
It was saying only about it as sine qua non. Other things can be taken unto account also.
I do not see the reason why pagans should be allowed to settle here at all, even if they are R1.
If they would want to, they should make some work - for example be baptized at the beginning.

Nice, we have many shit Pakistanis here in Greece.
I will tell to your R1a brothers to go in Poland

[DarknessWin]

We have an agreement then.

Poland will give citizenship rights to all Central & South Asian R1 Christians.

And indians, LOL