Cushitic vs Albanian Nasheed. Which sounds better?

[Wadaad]

Same Islamic nasheed, in two different language families and styles.

1) CUSHITIC (Djibouti)



2) ALBANIAN

[Linebacker]

I'll have you know that Albania is fully Catholics.Like 103%,do you understand?

The Wikipedia statistics are daily edited by Serbs and those video are made by Serbian agency with paid Serbian actors.

Do you understand this?!.!?!?!?

[Wadaad]

More importantly...notice the Cushites did not adopt an Arabic Musical Scale...kept it still native, with native inflection rhythms, etc. Cushitic words sung to a Cushitic beat.


While Albanians adopted Arabic musical scale and instruments and even singing style. Basically Albo lyrics over Arabic hymns and sounds.

[Wadaad]

I think how a society conducts their nasheeds says alot.

One group know that the "Arab" character is not important...another group get pseudo-Arabized.

I noticed non-Arabic nasheeds fall in one or the other category.

[Wadaad]

The people you'd think are the biggest "Arab wannabes": Pakistanis, Somalis, Bengalis, Indonesians etc.. actually keep their pre-Islamic cultural nuance intact in their nasheeds:

Pakis: (Very South Asian and not that much different from Indian music)






Contrast with Turkish nasheed (turks here act superior to Arabs...yet their nasheeds are Arab wannabe)

[Dema]

They both sound very bad... But if i would have to chose i would pick Albanian one... But seriously, musically, they are both very bad..



They cant compare to real Nasheed:

[Böri]

Cushite sounds better. the so-called Albanian one is half English. And the Turkish one is song by a Kurd like it's mentioned in the very beginning of the video.
Turkish sounds weird when talked or song by Kurds or Arabs who talk it with their accent, producing voices from deep throat (Turks talk with tongue end).

[Ghazi]

this is the best Nasheed

[Wadaad]

They both sound very bad... But if i would have to chose i would pick Albanian one... But seriously, musically, they are both very bad..



They cant compare to real Nasheed:

I wanna hear a true Albanian nasheed, in a Shqiptar style with native rhythms and tones.

A Nasheed using this rhythm would be cool:

[Wadaad]

Cushite sounds better. the so-called Albanian one is half English. And the Turkish one is song by a Kurd like it's mentioned in the very beginning of the video.
Turkish sounds weird when talked or song by Kurds or Arabs who talk it with their accent, producing voices from deep throat (Turks talk with tongue end).

Even I noticed this. Turkish is a nice language for ballads/nasheeds IMO.