Germanness in the 19th century

[Aren]

Read again until you get it.

Yes it's true PIE was brought by R1-people but Proto-Germanic didn't evolve until several thousands years later. So saying that I1 isn't Germanic is kinda false since people with I1 contributed to the evolvment of the language during the Iron Age and were by that time equally autosomally Germanic as those R1b and R1a men.

[Bobby Martnen]

Yes it's true PIE was brought by R1-people but Proto-Germanic didn't evolve until several thousands years later. So saying that I1 isn't Germanic is kinda false since people with I1 contributed to the evolvment of the language during the Iron Age and were by that time equally autosomally Germanic as those R1b and R1a men.

It's strange the way Rethel is trying to make I-men out to be non-European, given that unlike his people, we actually originated in Europe.

[Rethel]

It's strange the way Rethel is trying to make I-men out to be non-European, given that unlike his people, we actually originated in Europe.

Your abilites to comprehend what is talking about are amazing....

[Bobby Martnen]

Your abilites to comprehend what is talking about are amazing....

They're still better than your ability to speak English properly.

[Rethel]

They're still better than your ability to speak English properly.

Anybody else has no problem. So stop to hide behind it. It is ridiculous.

[Bobby Martnen]

Anybody else has no problem. So stop to hide behind it. It is ridiculous.

[Peterski]

It's strange the way Rethel is trying to make I-men out to be non-European, given that unlike his people, we actually originated in Europe.

Where do you think did R1a and R1b originate? Or R1 in general?

[Bobby Martnen]

Where do you think did R1a and R1b originate? Or R1 in general?

Didn't they originate in Central Asia? And then migrate to Europe and bring their language with them?