Which is the more Germanic haplogroup - I1, R1a, or R1b?

[Bobby Martnen]

Mexicans are actually spreading Spanish and Jewish Y-DNA by mixing with American women, lol. Anyway, many half Mexicans look white.

Mexicans haplos are not really compatible with Anglo-Americans, we don't really have a lot of R1b. Anglo-Americans are mostly I1, with a little R1b.

[Ayman Vasconic]

Obviously the answer is I1.

Can't be. Germanics are Indo-Europeans. I-people are not Indo-Europeans = I-people are no Germanics. Much more are not more germanic than two other groups mentioned by you.

[Bobby Martnen]

Can't be.
Germanics are Indo-Europeans.
I-people are not Indo-Europeans.
= I-people are no Germanics. Much
more are not more germanic than two
other groups mentioned by you.

Rethel?

[Rethel]

Obviously the answer is I1.

[Bobby Martnen]

I1 is proto-Germanic. Also, welcome back, Rethel. What were you even banned for in the first place?

[Rethel]

I1 is proto-Germanic.

Nope.
If you use word proto, then it is even
more R1, than without this word.

Also, welcome back, Rethel. What were you even banned for in the first place?

Inter alia becasue of you.

[Dragoon]

What is the percentage of I1 among Germans and Austrians?

16% in Germans (north has more than south)
12% in Austrians.

for comparison...

34% Denmark
12% England
9% Poland
9% France
5% Russia
2% Spain

[Wrong]

I1 is proto-Germanic. Also, welcome back, Rethel. What were you even banned for in the first place?

Nope. It was Indo-Europeanized by the R1 true Germanics before moving to Scandinavia and seeking refugee there, evolving from one man just 3000 years ago.. Just like J2 was Indo-Europeanized by R1.

There, I said it.. I1 was spread by one Indo-Europeanized man 3000 years ago.

[Dragoon]

Not sure how accurate this is:

https://www.eupedia.com/europe/europ...logroups.shtml

They say Mesolithic Europeans

I1 = Nordic (pre-Germanic)
12b = pre-Celto-Germanic
12a1 = Sardinian, Iberian
12a2 = Dinaric, Danubian

then...

Bronze Age

R1a = Baltic-Slavic, Germanic, Iranian
R1b = Italo-Celtic, Germanic.


So basically Germanic came with IndoEuropeans and Germanized the earlier ones? (maybe similar with Slavic coming with IndoEuropeans and Slavicizing others?)
Not sure.

[Wrong]

Rethel?

I1 was heavily Neolithic and positioned in Central Europe before getting Indo-Europeanized, nearly dying off until one man took refugee with the invading R1's in Scandinavia. Scandinavians still have Ancient Neolithic words, unknown to Indo-European.