0
Thumbs Up |
Received: 40,067 Given: 10,740 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 52,720 Given: 43,625 |
Norse influence in Ireland is significant, all Irish have it this one just more than is usual.
To add, I would never expect Iberian like input in Ireland, but in Wales yes.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 9,295 Given: 26,310 |
I found another Irish GEDmatch that has similar results
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...09#post5098709
Thumbs Up |
Received: 25,098 Given: 28,473 |
I wouldn't call it very atypical. On Gedmatch it is common to not all get your country as no 1 especially for Northwest Europeans. My no 1 country on K13 is North Dutch but Norwegian is at No 3 and my numbers are closer so I don't think you can call these results very atypical.
Admix Results (sorted):
# Population Percent
1 North_Atlantic 51.64
2 Baltic 25.42
3 West_Med 10.03
4 West_Asian 7.24
5 East_Med 1.8
6 Red_Sea 1.6
7 Amerindian 1.32
8 Siberian 0.71
9 Oceanian 0.23
Single Population Sharing:
# Population (source) Distance
1 North_Dutch 2.76
2 Irish 3.04
3 Norwegian 3.45
4 Danish 3.65
5 West_Scottish 3.67
6 Orcadian 3.69
7 North_German 5.11
8 Southeast_English 5.94
9 Southwest_English 6.16
10 Swedish 6.26
11 South_Dutch 9.92
12 West_German 10.75
13 North_Swedish 12.59
14 Austrian 14.89
15 East_German 15.05
16 French 15.64
17 Hungarian 19.19
18 Southwest_Finnish 20.83
19 Spanish_Cataluna 23.04
20 South_Polish 23.81
Mixed Mode Population Sharing:
# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 55.5% Irish + 44.5% Norwegian @ 2.13
2 52.6% Norwegian + 47.4% West_Scottish @ 2.25
3 74.9% Irish + 25.1% Swedish @ 2.34
4 57.3% North_Dutch + 42.7% Irish @ 2.35
5 86.9% Irish + 13.1% North_Swedish @ 2.4
6 67.7% North_Dutch + 32.3% West_Scottish @ 2.43
7 67.9% West_Scottish + 32.1% Swedish @ 2.45
8 93.6% Irish + 6.4% Finnish @ 2.45
9 72% Irish + 28% North_German @ 2.5
10 94.6% Irish + 5.4% East_Finnish @ 2.51
11 92.3% Irish + 7.7% Southwest_Finnish @ 2.51
12 94% Irish + 6% La_Brana-1 @ 2.53
13 96.1% Irish + 3.9% Chuvash @ 2.53
14 62.7% West_Scottish + 37.3% North_German @ 2.55
15 95.6% Irish + 4.4% Erzya @ 2.58
16 94.6% Irish + 5.4% Estonian @ 2.58
17 61.8% Irish + 38.2% Danish @ 2.6
18 96.7% Irish + 3.3% Mari @ 2.6
19 95% Irish + 5% Ukrainian_Belgorod @ 2.61
20 94.9% Irish + 5.1% Belorussian @ 2.62
Gedmatch gives Northwestern Europeans all different no 1 pops. I bet there are Norwegians that get Ireland as their no 1 pop as well.
Anyway if people looked at genetic plots over the years some of these results shouldn't really be a surprise. An oldie but a good one is the Novembre plot if you ignore the out of place Slovakian. West Irish are in fact more distant genetically to most other Europeans because they are geographically more distant. Scandinavians were sailors and the Norse did target Ireland and Scotland so there is nothing really very odd about them being somewhat closer genetically.
It's been known for years that the Irish don't have any special link with Iberians or Basques and I've posted about it frequently on here and some people got their knickers in a knot about it. I just post what I observe and also what I can link. But all this sort of stuff I've posted a while back. Got some grief from it as well. It's not strange that Irish would be closer to their neighbours than other populations. Logic is always a good thing to make use of.
This person that Sikeliot posted has very high North Sea so that would pull them closer to Norwegians as well.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 25,098 Given: 28,473 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 25,098 Given: 28,473 |
Wales doesn't have any extra Iberian like input either. If you look at the Irish DNA Atlas they are similar to other British and Irish populations. Also this graphic was released earlier before the Irish DNA Atlas came out from the Irish Traveller study showing the Welsh to be very similar to the Irish and Scots.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 19,704 Given: 5,846 |
Trawl through the pre-Viking dna in iron age and bell beakers from Britain to see how it's possible for this.
Pre-viking age Ireland would be northern with less mid neolithic than England, France, south Netherlands, Belgium or Germany but closer to say Norway, Denmark and north Netherlands.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 25,098 Given: 28,473 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 19,704 Given: 5,846 |
The calculators for Iron Age are a bit muddled too and on K15 the NOrthumbrian Anglo Saxon scores closer to the Irish and Scots than to the SOuthern English. Perhaps it isnt the best calculator to use, being a bit old and based off modern populations.
R1b-U152
1 South_Dutch 7.22
2 North_German 8.7
3 Southwest_English 9.02
4 Southeast_English 9.3
5 Irish 9.88
R1b-U106
1 Irish 6.01
2 West_Scottish 6.08
3 North_German 6.23
4 Danish 6.36
5 North_Dutch 6.98
r1b-L21
1 Irish 4.3
2 West_Scottish 5.35
3 Southeast_English 5.8
4 North_German
5 North_Dutch 6.2
1 Orcadian 3.61
2 West_Scottish 6.12
3 Southeast_English 6.61
4 Southwest_English 6.61
5 North_Dutch 6.65
1 North_German 5.32
2 Danish 7.33
3 North_Dutch 7.84
4 South_Dutch 8.03
5 Southeast_English 8.41
I1 Anglo Saxon
1 West_Norwegian 5.46
2 Norwegian 7.4
3 Swedish 8.22
4 Orcadian 9.89
5 North_Dutch 9.92
6 Danish 10.32
7 North_Swedish 10.68
8 West_Scottish 11.27
9 Irish 12.25
10 Southeast_English 13.07
11 North_German 13.42
12 Southwest_English 13.97
Thumbs Up |
Received: 19,704 Given: 5,846 |
Ran some Bell Beakers and noticed the Med Shift mainly in Italian.
Italian K36
11.47 --- Bell Beaker Britain I2a (U5a1a1)
9.61 --- Iron Age Britain R1b U-152
7.80 --- Bell Beaker Britain R1b-L21 (H1)
6.31 --- Iron age Britain r1b u-106
5.58 --- Modern Ireland
5.56 --- Iron Age Britain r1b-L21
4.72 --- Iron Age Britain r1b-L21
4.12 --- Iron Age Britain r1b-L21
1.88 --- Bell Beaker Germany
0.00 --- Iron Age Anglo Saxon England I1-S107
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (J1c)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (K1a26)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (H1e1a)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (T2b)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (V)
0.00 --- BB r1b-L21 (U4b1b2)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain r1b-L21 (HV0+195)
0.00 --- Bell Beaker Britain R1a1a
0.00 --- Bronze age Ireland R1b-L21
Last edited by Graham; 04-28-2018 at 08:45 AM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks