Germanic–Balto-Slavic and Satem (‘Indo-Slavonic’) dialect revisionism by amateur geneticists, or why

[Dibran]

I don't necessarily agree entirely with the position, however, there are certain aspects of their argument that seem feasible. I do not know the credentials(or lack thereof) of this individual.

Figured I would post it for discussion. Their position is that R1a/Corded Ware were originally Uralic speakers, assimilated by Proto-Indo-Europeans from the Yamnaya culture. Some of their arguments seem contradictory, others though provoking.

Discuss.

https://indo-european.eu/2017/07/ger...indo-european/

[Root]

anthropologically, culturally, geographically and almost linguistically and genetically Slavs (Polish, Ukrainians, Czech, Slovakians, Slovenes, Serbo-Croatians and Belarussians), Baltic peoples and Germanic peoples are definitely close to each other than to anyone else.. both are noble European master groups.

[Dibran]

anthropologically, culturally, geographically and almost linguistically and genetically Slavs (Polish, Ukrainians, Czech, Slovakians, Serbo-Croatians and Belarussians), Baltic peoples and Germanic peoples are definitely close to each other than to anyone else.. both are noble European master groups.

I don't see what that has to do with the article. I am sure you didn't read it lol.

[Root]

I don't see what that has to do with the article. I am sure you didn't read it lol.

nope, my opinion has nothing to do with the article and its content, but these subgroups are closer to each other in all matters..

[Dibran]

nope, my opinion has nothing to do with the article and its content, but these subgroups are closer to each other in all matters..

Ok. I understand that. You should read it. It is interesting. Would like to discuss it.