Balto-Slavic, was it?

[Vlatko Vukovic]

Svaanik Kumar explains that I2a was closer to Sanskrit (he compares Sanskrit to South Slavic), so basically they can be called Slavic language owners, R1a were from different branch, they took influences, R1a are Slavic language users (like Celtic Irish people are Germanic English (I1) language users)

How if I2a is not Indo-European

[Vlatko Vukovic]

It is my opinion that Scythians have completely assimilated South-Eastern Balto-Slavic Group of peoples and created the language we call Slavic.

That is where we have problem.

Did they assimilated Balto-Slavic group, or just Baltic group

[Dick]

Svaanik Kumar explains that I2a was closer to Sanskrit (he compares Sanskrit to South Slavic), so basically they can be called Slavic language owners, R1a were from different branch, they took influences, R1a are Slavic language users (like Celtic Irish people are Germanic English (I1) language users)

So you think Slavs originated in the Danube basin/ Vinca?. What would Marija Gimbutas say.

[Ülev]

How if I2a is not Indo-European

don't listen to R1 knight anymore

[Bosniensis]

How if I2a is not Indo-European

I2 is Proto-Carpatian haplogroup that has been assimilated into that Indo-Iranian and Proto Slavic mix.

We will never know, but I tend to trust OLD Greek authors cause they always spoke with confidence like "that's undisputed fact".

[Dick]

yabhti = JEBAT

http://spokensanskrit.org/index.php?...ink=yes&mode=3

[Vlatko Vukovic]

don't listen to R1 knight anymore

Hahaha, so your opinion is that I2a spoke Indo-European language as well? From the beginning?

[Bosniensis]

http://spokensanskrit.org/index.php?...ink=yes&mode=3

Samo yabhti da da

[Vlatko Vukovic]

http://spokensanskrit.org/index.php?...ink=yes&mode=3

I think that Letto-Lithuanian Balts are swearing totally different

[Ülev]

How if I2a is not Indo-European

don't listen to R1 knight anymore

http://eujournal.org/index.php/esj/a...File/4182/4018

THE STORY OF TWO NORTHWARD MIGRATIONS - ORIGINS OF FINNO - PERMIC AND BALTO - SLAVIC LANGUAGES IN NORTHEAST EUROPE, BASED ON HUMAN Y - CHROMOSOME HAPLOGROUPS

Abstract
This paper attemps to find a plausible explanation for the origins of Balto
-
Slavic and Finno-Permian languages in Northeast Europe by a research based on the analysis of statistical databases of human Y-chromosome haplogroups . The mainstream view that
associates Balto-Slavic languages with haplogroup R1a and íthe Corded Ware Culture, and Finno-Permian languages with haplogroup N, fails to solve several contradictions: How
come, that the presence of subclades of haplogroup R are as high in most Finno-Permian populations, as the presence of haplogroup N? How come, that Corded Ware culture spread
so far north, that it covered the early-medieval range of most Finno-Permic languages? This
paper is trying to set up a hypothesis that solves these contradictions.

in short, they wrote:
R1a (Z280) was Uralic/Permian, N1 Finnic
when I2a came (probably with R1a m-458) we have those Slavic dialects