0
Thumbs Up |
Received: 829 Given: 276 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 65 Given: 95 |
Lol. I do not see what are you gaining by merely saying these stuff. I am clearly not a Christian, but an Agnostic who's merely interested in Stoicism. Nothing more or less.
Indeed. Although I do not understand how do you have the audacity to reply after claiming to believe in a Turkic fantasy world. "Oldest people in the word", indeed, yet nothing was mentioned about till the Mongol invasion and the Seljuqs. Turkic bronze age? Never heard of that.
And yet here you also committed a fallacy by assuming I believe in a "magic disappearance act" of the Sumerians. The Sumerians never disappeared. They rather assimilated into the Akkadian-speaking Semite invaders from the West. Sumerian was still written until the 1st century CE.
Akkadian gradually replaced Sumerian as a spoken language around 2000 BC (the exact dating being subject to debate), but Sumerian continued to be used as a sacred, ceremonial, literary and scientific language in Akkadian-speaking Mesopotamian states such as Assyria and Babylonia until the 1st century AD.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 829 Given: 276 |
Disappearing act was referring to not only sumerians or Etrusks but others too ; like the Commagenes for example or Kumukia .
My claim can actually be phrased as follows ; " Etruscans were a Caucasian people from Caucasus and Anatolia . "
Imho , linguisticly speaking Etruscan is partially Turkish and partially made up of other Caucasian language groups , such as Basques , Illirians , Avars etc etc .
When you say that Turks only arrived in Anatolia ; all the rock carvings in Anatolia says the opposite .
The evidence on the ground says Turks have been in Anatolia far longer than the narrative teaches .
Anyhow , your model says " we don't know " but Turk's model explains it better with common words , rituals , cultural clues and genetics .
Unlike you , I don't refer to authority ; I use objective reasoning ; i can actually read the inscriptions of Etrusks .
,
Thumbs Up |
Received: 829 Given: 276 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 65 Given: 95 |
There is no such thing as "disappeared". Etruscans simply assimilated in the Roman society and many were given Roman citizenship and even rose to equestrian ranks and Senators. Same thing happened to the Sumerians as I explained above.
You see, we are not 100% sure where did the Etruscans come from. They could have been Aegeans, Anatolians and they could have been Steppe people. Your claim is not backed up. Neither is any of the above claims I mentioned. I think the high frequency of R1b and the presence of mitochondrial DNA that is close to that of Levantines may suggest some Bronze age events that we do not know yet
Basque is an isolate language, first of all.
Illyrian is Indo-European.
Avar is Northeast Caucasian.
None of these languages are directly related, as you can see. Your claim is virtually useless and not backed by any evidence among mainstream scientists and researchers.
What rock carvings? Hittite carvings? Phyrgian? Lydian? Latin? Greek????? Are you even reading what I am writing?
During the 11th century the Seljuk Turks who were admirers of the Persian civilization grew in number and were able to occupy the eastern province of the Abbasid Empire. By 1055, the Seljuk Empire captured Baghdad and began to make their first incursions into the edges of Anatolia. There is absolutely nothing to suggest that Turks ruled/settled Anatolia before the 11th century.
The first established records of the Turkic languages are the eighth century AD Orkhon inscriptions by the Göktürks, recording the Old Turkic language, which were discovered in 1889 in the Orkhon Valley in Mongolia.
Indeed. Quite frankly, there is nothing, on this earth, more objective and rational than claiming a civilization that existed 2900-3000 years ago was a subset of a greater culture that was born later, thousands of kilometers away and share absolutely no linguistic or cultural connections.
perhaps you can tell me what is written here without googling the image:
smp_etruscan (1).gif
Thumbs Up |
Received: 829 Given: 276 |
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks