Who is closer to Judaism? islam or christianity(jews answer)

[Hurrem sultana]

Here is an interesting video from Jerusalem ..average jews about who they consider to be more similar to them,i am suprised a majority of jews seem to see islam as closer to judaism than christianty ..i thought our hate for eachother would make us deny fact ?

[Sikeliot]

Islam and Christianity are closer than either one is to Judaism.

[Ryuk]

Islam and Christianity are closer than either one is to Judaism.

I do not agree,Christianity is heavily influenced by European pagan beliefs.

Islam is more closer than its Semitic roots,so it is closer to Judaism.

[Phenix]

Very honest answers, Christianity is a European religion while Judaism and Islam are Semitic cults.

Islam and Christianity are closer than either one is to Judaism.

I do not agree,Christianity is heavily influenced by European pagan beliefs.

Islam is more closer than its Semitic roots,so it is closer to Judaism.

Link between Christianity an Islam is their universal range, both are adhesion proposals, the contrary of tribalist Judaism. One might say Islam is halfway between the two, your words are not contradictory.

[Hurrem sultana]

Very honest answers, Christianity is a European religion while Judaism and Islam are Semitic cults.




Link between Christianity an Islam is their universal range, both are adhesion proposals, the contrary of tribalist Judaism. One might say Islam is halfway between the two, your words are not contradictory.

how is islam and judaism cult while christianity european? and most of the christians of the planet earth are not europeans

sure islam and judaism have some common basic grounds,like they view on God same way while christians have the trinty (which is a huge sin in both islam and judaism)

[Longbowman]

They're similar in different ways.

Christianity and Islam are 'one true path' religions in which the messiah has in effect already come. Islam also more or less accepts the Christian lore and builds on it. Judaism does not accept Christian lore.

Judaism and Islam are more monotheistic and their pagan influences are less obvious. They also have more focus on ritual restrictions and prayer than Christianity has.

Judaism and Christianity are superficially similar in the values of their practitioners due to shared history.

Islam is closer to both than either are to each other though.

[Óttar]

Islam and Judaism both affirm the oneness of God (Tawhid) proclaiming Eloheinu Adonai Achad and Allahu Wahid ("God is one"). Neither one has room for a trinity. The fact that Islam accepts Jesus as a prophet merely defangs him. In Christianity, Jesus has THE central role in the work of salvation; every event is merely a footnote making way for his arrival.

Judaism has the rabbis who interpret the Talmud and Islam has the Sunnah, the traditions of the Prophet. Not to mention cultural similarities like Hebrew and Arabic both being West Semitic languages, and Jews and Muslims both maintaining beards and skull-caps.

[Iẓeḍwan n Nanna-Tuda]

I'm not surprised at all.
As other fellows have stressed, both religions share a lot, especially their strict monotheism.

However (that's a bit off-topic), I think that Islam had to emerge from a Jewish sect who was recognizing Jesus as the Massiah but not his divinity...

[Longbowman]

I'm not surprised at all.
As other fellows have stressed, both religions share a lot, especially their strict monotheism.

However (that's a bit off-topic), I think that Islam had to emerge from a Jewish sect who was recognizing Jesus as the Massiah but not his divinity...

like Jehovah's Witnesses?

Islam was directly inspired by Christianity, not Judaism, but in character remained between the two.

[Root]

I strongly recommend you to open this web link below and read its content very carefully.. obviously Muslims are closer to Jews or vice versa

http://www.judaism-islam.com/similar...ism-and-islam/