Independent Kurdistan: would you support it?

[Oghuz]

I would say that wholeheartedly, it wont stop, it will get worse and worse. Iran has executed many kurds because of it already. Seperatist kurds dying day by day. Im not really happy for it. I wish i can stop it but this topic doesnt work like that.

Iranic Kurds separated from Iranic Iran ? That is like saying Anatolian Turkish should separate from Rest of the Turkey.

PJAK, KDPI, KOMALA are all foreign funded organizations and they often receive our Ballistic Missiles landing right on their heads in their homes in Iraq or wherever they create bases with CIA money. You are too dumb to even realize that Iranian government is actually aligned with Turkey against US/Israeli funded Kurdish insurgency. PKK have virtually no presence in Iran and never has been supported by post revolution Iran. None of these organizations have any real ground support in Iranian Kurdistan based on one strong fact. Iranian Kurds are majority Shiites who would gain nothing by getting out of Shiite Umbrella of Iranian theocracy. They have their shiite and Kurdish identity secure inside Iran compared to Baathist Arab or Turkish experiences.

My own personal opinion is that Kurds should get a separate country in Non Iranic Countries. Inside Iran Kurds are just another Shiite Iranic ethnicity in a large Iranic country like Lurs, Persians etc.

Its a none issue anyways. Kurds will become problem in Turkey because of breeding rate, its not my or any Iranians concern.

[Kyp]

Sunni Kurds will never have peace being between two chauvinistic powers like Turkey and Persians.

[Oghuz]

Kurds dna most similiar to iranians. Their original homeland is iran. They immigrated to Turkey and lived in peaceful. So you are here and saying that kurds must get the turkish lands but not iranian lands, their homeland. You must be stupid

Kurds have been habitating in their areas long before Oghuz Turks changed Anatolian DNA to 15-20 % "Turkish".

Kurds are Iranic and inside Iran they are just another well integrated Iranic ethnicity. They are a problem for Baathist Arabs and Turkish with whome they share nothing. Its not the same for Iran, never have been except for bandit Shikaks.

[Oghuz]

Iran will break up for sure, Turkey never

No one will break up. Turkey will become Kurdish majority in next 20-30 years as Erdoo accepted himself. I see no border change otherwise.

[Negah]

Iran will break up for sure, Turkey never

Neither Iran nor Turkey are even close to breaking up what nonsense is that. If anything Iran is going to expand further as Afghanistan weakens when the US leaves. Herat area is essentially part of Iran even today, and northern Afghanistan's identity is rather fluid. For many centuries they were part of Iran and identified as such.

[Ford]

Maybe, but I only think Iraqi Kurds will manage to achieve independece in the foreseeable future (or at least they are currently the ones with the greatest chances). I don't think they're much of a threat to the other countries they inhabit, but they might gain traction depending on what situation the other host nations put themselves in.

[sailorsally77]

You dont even know if the kurds get independent, they will get that iran part for sure. But keep talking your worthless words. Kurds wont get any part of Turkey

Kurds have been habitating in their areas long before Oghuz Turks changed Anatolian DNA to 15-20 % "Turkish".

Kurds are Iranic and inside Iran they are just another well integrated Iranic ethnicity. They are a problem for Baathist Arabs and Turkish with whome they share nothing. Its not the same for Iran, never have been except for bandit Shikaks.

[Oghuz]

Sunni Kurds will never have peace being between two chauvinistic powers like Turkey and Persians.

please explain to me how come 49 % non ethnic Persian Iranian state can be termed as Persians?

[sailorsally77]

please explain to me how come 49 % non ethnic Persian Iranian state can be termed as Persians?

Because of your government you idiot. Your disgusting worthless government force them to identify theirselves as persians. You asimilate them.

[Oghuz]

Neither Iran nor Turkey is even close to breaking up what nonsense is that. If anything Iran is going to expand further as Afghanistan weakens when the US leaves. Herat area is essentially part of Iran even today, and northern Afghanistan's identity is rather fluid. For many centuries they were part of Iran and identified as such.

Good post dadash.

I also see this happening, Afghanistan will collapse on its own because of Civil war. Herat needs to be retaken.