0
Thumbs Up |
Received: 7,243 Given: 2,623 |
This study is greatly biased becasue it is partly or mainly based on self-assesment of hair color by study participants. We know how, especially women are biased about their real hair color. Common people especially are useless in dividing between light brown and dark blond category. I'm not sure also how this dermatologist who examined some Polish participants was trained. If he used Martin scale for hair color? I guess not. If it was his observation only it is bullshit, becasue without proper scale to compare he was biased becasue during the day even level of natural light can change color perception.
Only up to date anthropometric journey in Poland was in 1955-1956 when they examined about 13 722 Polish men and 14 043 women form all regions - Górny S., Zdjęcie antropometryczne Polski. Cz. 1: Pomiary ludności dorosłej z lat 1955-56 [w:] Materiały i Prace Antropologiczne, nr 84, 1972
As you see this study wasn't biased to prove great Polish blondness and was made by real anthropologists.
men 17-67 (Martin scale)
- light blond (A-L, I, III) 6.74%
- dark blond and red (this minimally) (M-Q, II,V-VI ) 23.05%
- light brown (R-S) 13.05%
- medium brown (T-U) 26.51%
- dark brown mainly, pure black minimal (V-Y) 30.65%
women 17-67 (Martin scale)
- light blond (A-L, I, III) 6.32%
- dark blond and red (this minimally (M-Q, II,V-VI ) 23.8%
- light brown (R-S) 14.51%
- medium brown (T-U) 26.61%
- dark brown mainly, pure black minimal (V-Y) 28.76%
Map is wrong. It is colorized Coon map of both hair and eyes color mixed with Peter Frost map.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 1,585 Given: 538 |
The Germans
Thumbs Up |
Received: 1,195 Given: 677 |
You're right. Only small error: scale is Fisher-Saller; Martin is for eye color
Thumbs Up |
Received: 7,243 Given: 2,623 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 2,181 Given: 3 |
By this genetic map, most of Germany and Poland are similar, but South Germany seems much darker.
https://unsafeharbour.files.wordpres...ationgenes.jpg
Thumbs Up |
Received: 2,181 Given: 3 |
Idiotic! England is a light-haired country as a whole, not necessarily blond in the Scandinavian sense. It is much more blonde than Italy! No comparison, what is your point? This is another map based on genes for light hair and light eyes, way more precise than the 19th century one. It is based on 21st century study! OK!!! Look at Italy and then England!
https://unsafeharbour.files.wordpres...ationgenes.jpg
Thumbs Up |
Received: 2,181 Given: 3 |
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks