Are Slovaks closer to Czechs or Hungarians ?

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

Discuss and vote.

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

UP

[Mikula]

IMHO people from western Slovakia are close to people from Moravia (the estern part of the Czech Republic)

[Ülev]

TA taugh me that the first are unique

[Grace O'Malley]

They are closer to Czechs. The Czechs are the closest modern population to the Slovaks on G25. They were one country after all.

9 Slovakian:Average Czech_Averaged Averaged 2.275
10 Slovakian:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 2.326
30 Slovakian:Average Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 2.829
33 Slovakian:Average Hungarian_Averaged Averaged 2.89
49 Slovakian:Average Croatian_Averaged Averaged 3.156
50 Slovakian:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 3.172
54 Slovakian:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 3.225
76 Slovakian:Average Russian_Voronez_Averaged Averaged 3.367
85 Slovakian:Average Russian_Kursk_Averaged Averaged 3.444
97 Slovakian:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 3.613
139 Slovakian:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 3.917
143 Slovakian:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 3.959
160 Slovakian:Average Belarusian_Averaged Averaged 4.073

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

They are closer to Czechs. The Czechs are the closest modern population to the Slovaks on G25. They were one country after all.

9 Slovakian:Average Czech_Averaged Averaged 2.275
10 Slovakian:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 2.326
30 Slovakian:Average Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 2.829
33 Slovakian:Average Hungarian_Averaged Averaged 2.89
49 Slovakian:Average Croatian_Averaged Averaged 3.156
50 Slovakian:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 3.172
54 Slovakian:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 3.225
76 Slovakian:Average Russian_Voronez_Averaged Averaged 3.367
85 Slovakian:Average Russian_Kursk_Averaged Averaged 3.444
97 Slovakian:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 3.613
139 Slovakian:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 3.917
143 Slovakian:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 3.959
160 Slovakian:Average Belarusian_Averaged Averaged 4.073

Slovaks and Hungarians were one country for 1000 years though. But yeah it seems they're quite closer to Czechs.
mind to post averages for Czechs and Hungarians ?

[Grace O'Malley]

No problems. Looking at this Hungarians and Czechs appear a bit more western shifted. What do you think?

1 Hungarian:Average Croatian_Averaged Averaged 1.17
2 Hungarian:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 1.416
3 Hungarian:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 1.673
4 Hungarian:Average Czech_Averaged Averaged 1.729
13 Hungarian:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 2.158
14 Hungarian:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 2.17
27 Hungarian:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 2.492
36 Hungarian:Average German_Averaged Averaged 2.657
110 Hungarian:Average Montenegrin_Averaged Averaged 3.437
131 Hungarian:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 3.582
142 Hungarian:Average Serbian_Averaged Averaged 3.699
145 Hungarian:Average French_East_Averaged Averaged 3.797
173 Hungarian:Average Dutch_Averaged Averaged 3.953
174 Hungarian:Average Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 3.96

2 Czech:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 1.64
3 Czech:Average Hungarian_Averaged Averaged 1.729
10 Czech:Average Slovakian_Averaged Averaged 2.275
13 Czech:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 2.3
23 Czech:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 2.523
28 Czech:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 2.586
45 Czech:Average German_Averaged Averaged 2.801
84 Czech:Average Swedish_Averaged Averaged 3.216
120 Czech:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 3.558
133 Czech:Average Cossack_Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 3.611
134 Czech:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 3.614
152 Czech:Average Dutch_Averaged Averaged 3.762
165 Czech:Average Russian_Voronez_Averaged Averaged 3.837
172 Czech:Average Russian_Orel_Averaged Averaged 3.893
210 Czech:Average Norwegian_Averaged Averaged 4.09

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

No problems. Looking at this Hungarians and Czechs appear a bit more western shifted. What do you think?

1 Hungarian:Average Croatian_Averaged Averaged 1.17
2 Hungarian:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 1.416
3 Hungarian:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 1.673
4 Hungarian:Average Czech_Averaged Averaged 1.729
13 Hungarian:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 2.158
14 Hungarian:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 2.17
27 Hungarian:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 2.492
36 Hungarian:Average German_Averaged Averaged 2.657
110 Hungarian:Average Montenegrin_Averaged Averaged 3.437
131 Hungarian:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 3.582
142 Hungarian:Average Serbian_Averaged Averaged 3.699
145 Hungarian:Average French_East_Averaged Averaged 3.797
173 Hungarian:Average Dutch_Averaged Averaged 3.953
174 Hungarian:Average Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 3.96

2 Czech:Average German_East_Averaged Averaged 1.64
3 Czech:Average Hungarian_Averaged Averaged 1.729
10 Czech:Average Slovakian_Averaged Averaged 2.275
13 Czech:Average Slovenian_Averaged Averaged 2.3
23 Czech:Average Polish_Averaged Averaged 2.523
28 Czech:Average Austrian_Averaged Averaged 2.586
45 Czech:Average German_Averaged Averaged 2.801
84 Czech:Average Swedish_Averaged Averaged 3.216
120 Czech:Average Moldovan_Averaged Averaged 3.558
133 Czech:Average Cossack_Ukrainian_Averaged Averaged 3.611
134 Czech:Average Bosnian_Averaged Averaged 3.614
152 Czech:Average Dutch_Averaged Averaged 3.762
165 Czech:Average Russian_Voronez_Averaged Averaged 3.837
172 Czech:Average Russian_Orel_Averaged Averaged 3.893
210 Czech:Average Norwegian_Averaged Averaged 4.09

Slovaks are more purely Slavic, I guess.

[Vojnik]

No brainer. Similar language. Shared same country at one stage. And i'm sure they have much more cultural and historical ties. Czechs and Slovaks.

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

No brainer. Similar language. Shared same country at one stage. And i'm sure they have much more cultural and historical ties. Czechs and Slovaks.

Not really though. I am amazed how ignorant about history some people are. Slovaks shared same country with Hungarians for a millenium and same country with Czechs for less than 100 years.
(unless you count Great Moravian times)
They're genetically and linguistically obviously closer to Czechs. Hungarians are closer to Croats and Czechs to East Germans though.

I ran some Slovak gedmatch kits and quite a few have south Polish/West Ukrainian affinity but some others are quite more southern and western shifted.