stronger Germanic influence, Finland or Slovenia?

[Blondie]

SW Finland, I guess.

Slovenes are closer to Austrians than Finns are to Swedes, but Austrians aren't that Germanic to begin with.

No, they aren't. Finns are closer to swedes.

[Papastratosels26]

Finland

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

Paternal origin of Austria: 46,5% celto-germanic, 26% slavic
Paternal origin of Slovenia: 58,5% slavic, 28,5% celto-germanic

https://www.eupedia.com/europe/europ...logroups.shtml

Slovenes and austrians are clearly different population and majority of austrians have no slavic origin, they aren't german speaker slovenes.

Not really. They're pretty close on autosomal tests.

Austrians in Styria and Carinthia do have Slovenian origins. Graz is over 40% R1a.

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

No, they aren't. Finns are closer to swedes.

Not even close lol. Finns are like 10% mongoloid and closer to Northern Russians than to Swedes. SW Finns are close to Swedes though.
Slovenians are close to Austrians, wtf you're talking about ?

My full Slovene DNA relative gedmatch:

Admix Results (sorted):

1 Atlantic 22.65
2 Baltic 19.77
3 North_Sea 18.04
4 Eastern_Euro 15.9
5 West_Med 11.6
6 East_Med 4.89
7 West_Asian 4.68
8 Red_Sea 2.48

Single Population Sharing:

1 Austrian 5.01
2 Croatian 5.88
3 Hungarian 8.09
4 East_German 8.26
5 Moldavian 9.16
6 Serbian 9.66
7 South_Polish 10.12
8 Polish 11.39
9 Ukrainian_Lviv 11.45
10 Ukrainian 11.63
11 Russian_Smolensk 12.65
12 Romanian 12.88
13 Southwest_Finnish 13.99
14 Ukrainian_Belgorod 14.33
15 Southwest_Russian 14.47
16 Estonian_Polish 14.53
17 South_Dutch 14.76
18 Belorussian 14.95
19 Bulgarian 15.05
20 Finnish 15.95

[Alenka]

My full Slovene DNA relative gedmatch:

Is this population average or individual?

[Blondie]

Not really. They're pretty close on autosomal tests.

Austrians in Styria and Carinthia do have Slovenian origins. Graz is over 40% R1a.

Not all r1a type is slavic:
https://www.eupedia.com/europe/Haplo...shtml#Germanic

Finns are clearly closer to Swedes:



other map:



Finns have no 20% mongoloid genes

"According to "The ALlele FREquency Database" compiled by Kenneth K. Kidd of Yale University, between 3 and 6 percent of Finns have the 1540C allele on their EDAR (Ectodysplasin A receptor) gene.
There are noteworthy autosomal and uniparental differences between Eastern Finns and Western Finns. Eastern Finns have more (5-10%) of a pull in the direction of North Asia than Western Finns (3-4%) do, and their haplogroup distributions are different. "

"Of all populations, Finns are closest to Estonians followed by Swedes. "
http://www.khazaria.com/genetics/finns.html

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

Is this population average or individual?

Just one guy, he's related to me.

[Ülev]

Poland

[Alenka]

Just one guy, he's related to me.

What's the average like, is there a spreadsheet?

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

Not all r1a type is slavic:

In southern Austria it is. Germanic R1a is practically absent outside of Norway. Southern Austria was part of Slavic ''state'' Caranthania that was proto-Slovenian, so what's so suprising about that ?
It's western Austrians close to Switzerland who don't have any Slav blood, other Austrians do.



Caranthania was destroyed by Bavarian conquest later.