I'm 5% Ashkenazi Jewish. Do you consider me an Ashkenazi Jew?

[Blondie]

you can be 0% ashkenazi and still jewish, if you convert to judaism.

So if a 100% chinese guy would convert to judaism that this guy would be a jew and not chinese from that moment?

[Mortimer]

Yeah, except if that person is a practitioner of a religion that is not Judaism. They used to let in Messianics and other converts, though. But they stopped a while ago after determining that they weren't even Jewish-adjacent like quarter-Jews are (zera yisra'el, to use the Halakhic term). Whilst the non-Jewish descendant of a Jew has some minor status in halakha, a 'halakhic Jew' who practises a non-Jewish religion is an apikores or heretic and is supposed to be placed in kherem or excommunicated wholesale, if they're considered Jewish at all.

There is still a large-ish amount of Messianics and 'Jewish Christians' from before that law came into play, though.
.

Does that include Brother Nathanael Kemptner too as heretic and excommunicate? Is he even a jew still?

[Mortimer]

So if a 100% chinese guy would convert to judaism that this guy would be a jew and not chinese from that moment?

He would because jew is not a race it is like becoming american.

[Longbowman]

Does that include Brother Nathanael Kemptner too as heretic and excommunicate? Is he even a jew still?

He's mentally ill. A bullet in his skull would be for his benefit as well as everyone else. But of course he is not a member of the kehilla.

So if a 100% chinese guy would convert to judaism that this guy would be a jew and not chinese from that moment?

Both.

[Mortimer]

He's mentally ill. A bullet in his skull would be for his benefit as well as everyone else. But of course he is not a member of the kehilla.



Both.

indeed like becoming chinese-american. both chinese and american.

[Blondie]

He would because jew is not a race it is like becoming american.

So this chinese guy will be jew but an atheist person who has 100% jewish origin from his parents is not jew. lol this is bullshit

[Smeagol]

So if a 100% chinese guy would convert to judaism that this guy would be a jew and not chinese from that moment?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaifeng_Jews

[Longbowman]

So this chinese guy will be jew but an atheist person who has 100% jewish origin from his parents is not jew. lol this is bullshit

No, aethist Jews are Jews.

[Mortimer]

So this chinese guy will be jew but an atheist person who has 100% jewish origin from his parents is not jew. lol this is bullshit

the Atheist is also jew. and if the chinese in 5 years considers himself Atheist but converted legally in a Ultra orthodox court he is also still a jew. but Longbowman I think pointed out that if you practice another religion you are excommunicated but atheists dont practice another religion, they practice no religion.

[Daos777]

I never met a Jew with any kind of honor. They are always sneaky two faced pieces of shit. Who lack any form of basic human decency. They are also typically un-athletic and have small ass dicks and can’t compete with men at male activities so that’s why they resort to Jewry and manipulation.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk