[Question for Slav people] - Your Opinion on E-V13 Slav?

[Jana]

If you need to know one's DOB and time to give them an accurate reading, doesn't that make the whole thing about being Leo, Virgo, etc. pretty useless?

In my opinion, most of the descriptions are very general and apply to most people. I could just write up a set of characteristics that are super common (e.g. shy until you get to know people, having trouble staying motivated, overthinks a lot, etc.) and give it a specific date (like January 18). Then the person who was born on that day will think I'm an astrologist. You can watch James Randi debunking astrologists if you're interested. He basically has them pass a test to prove astrology is real and all of them fail.

But anyways, I don't have an issue with people that believe in it. It just looks like harmless fun. So I'm just curious what my reading says for the sake of it. I was born on July 28, 1996 at around 3:15 AM. I'm not 100% sure if it was exactly 3:15, maybe it's off by 2 minutes, but I don't think it would change the reading. If it does, oh well.

Astrology is not a guessing game. And I don't know you well enough to be able to make educated guess.
I don't take it seriously at all, it's great fun for me but I see some things right in it. I don't bother myself that much with legitimacy of astrology, it's just a fun hobby

I'll look in to your birth chart sometime later. Cheers!

[Ülev]

no idea, I am Finno-Permic
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...Slavic-looking

[pulstar]

If you need to know one's DOB and time to give them an accurate reading, doesn't that make the whole thing about being Leo, Virgo, etc. pretty useless?

In my opinion, most of the descriptions are very general and apply to most people. I could just write up a set of characteristics that are super common (e.g. shy until you get to know people, having trouble staying motivated, overthinks a lot, etc.) and give it a specific date (like January 18). Then the person who was born on that day will think I'm an astrologist. You can watch James Randi debunking astrologists if you're interested. He basically has them pass a test to prove astrology is real and all of them fail.

But anyways, I don't have an issue with people that believe in it. It just looks like harmless fun. So I'm just curious what my reading says for the sake of it. I was born on July 28, 1996 at around 3:15 AM. I'm not 100% sure if it was exactly 3:15, maybe it's off by 2 minutes, but I don't think it would change the reading. If it does, oh well.

All you ever need to know about astrology: