Classify these Afghan students

[bulunulu]

But that usually comes to the expense of lower south asian. So it's either the east eurasian is going in the south asian for afghans who score higher SA or the other way round.

Yeah, true that.

Had it not been for the turkic admix in AFG tajiks, i think most tajiks then would be slightly more south asian genetically than some regional pashtuns, since even some tajiks with high mong have as much aasi as i do. And i only get 2% mong, while they get 8-12%

[Avicenna]

Yeah, true that.

Had it not been for the turkic admix in AFG tajiks, i think most tajiks then would be slightly more south asian genetically than some regional pashtuns, since even some tajiks with high mong have as much aasi as i do. And i only get 2% mong, while they get 8-12%

No thats incorrect. This is why you shouldn't rely solely on admixture calculators. If you remove the turkic admix in certain tajiks, the south asian wouldn't alwsys go up. The South asian could be hiding alot of basal eurasian ancestry among afghans. This means that the south asian ( asi) could be overestimsted since it also contains a chunk of CHG.

[bulunulu]

No thats incorrect. This is why you shouldn't rely solely on admixture calculators. If you remove the turkic admix in certain tajiks, the south asian wouldn't alwsys go up. The South asian could be hiding alot of basal eurasian ancestry among afghans. This means that the south asian ( asi) could be overestimsted since it also contains a chunk of CHG.

Is there also a lot of CHG in the asi of desis?

[Avicenna]

Is there also a lot of CHG in the asi of desis?

That's a broad spectrum.

[Avicenna]

Is there also a lot of CHG in the asi of desis?

That's a broad spectrum.

[bulunulu]

That's a broad spectrum.

So its not the case for all desis?

[Avicenna]

So its not the case for all desis?

Desis range from rors, jatts to tribal South indians. Also, contrary to what people say, phenotype gives you a massive hint in a person's admixture. Group wise.Rors and jatts look like your typical desi Indian and yet they score the lowest south asian and highest steppe among desis. There must be a reason as to why they look desi.

[bulunulu]

Desis range from rors, jatts to tribal South indians. Also, contrary to what people say, phenotype gives you a massive hint in a person's admixture. Group wise.Rors and jatts look like your typical desi Indian and yet they score the lowest south asian and highest steppe among desis. There must be a reason as to why they look desi.

Well, admixture results kind of also gives them way less west asian admix(not gedrosian) when they have REALLY high steppe. And afghans might have as high steppe as these desis, but they have always twice to sometimes trice, but at least always more. ANd i assume the west asian admix makes you lighter too.

[Avicenna]

Well, admixture results kind of also gives them way less west asian admix(not gedrosian) when they have REALLY high steppe. And afghans might have as high steppe as these desis, but they have always twice to sometimes trice, but at least always more. ANd i assume the west asian admix makes you lighter too.

I guess so. We need ancient samples from those regions tbh. Right now it's alot of guesswork.

[bulunulu]

I guess so. We need ancient samples from those regions tbh. Right now it's alot of guesswork.

Actually, i got some few samples that have indo-aryan sub-clades, who could been ancestors of jatts. Theyre all placed around badakhshan though.