What Haplogroups can be considered white?

[The Sun King]

I'd like people's opinions on what haplogroups they consider as white. For myself. R1b, R1a, G2a l497, J2b, J2a, Ev13, I1, I2 , N all white.
Non white= Q, J1, all other subclades of E ex (e v22) G1 and all other subclades of G2 not belonging to the l497 branch , T , M, S, C, D, H (gypsy) L. Within the white haplogroups I would have a strict pecking order. 1.R1a 2.R1b. 3. I1. 4.I2 5. G2a l497 6.J2b 7.J2a 8.N 9.Ev13. Thoughts?

[Yamnaya]

R1a

[Token]

There are many other European clades of G2a other than L497. L497 is just the Alpine clade

[The Sun King]

There are many other European clades of G2a other than L497. L497 is just the Alpine clade

Yes your correct, I forgot U1. Thanks for picking that up.

[Ülev]

N1 - white of snow

[Blondie]

Neither, autosomal genetic does matter

[Hajimurad]

If haplogroups is an indicator of whiteness then Afro-American with R1b or I1 haplogroup is whiter than native Caucasian with J1 one.

[SUPREEEEEME]

I'd like people's opinions on what haplogroups they consider as white. For myself. R1b, R1a, G2a l497, J2b, J2a, Ev13, I1, I2 , N all white.
Non white= Q, J1, all other subclades of E ex (e v22) G1 and all other subclades of G2 not belonging to the l497 branch , T , M, S, C, D, H (gypsy) L. Within the white haplogroups I would have a strict pecking order. 1.R1a 2.R1b. 3. I1. 4.I2 5. G2a l497 6.J2b 7.J2a 8.N 9.Ev13. Thoughts?

It depends on what you define as "white".

I belong to J2a, which originated in the Middle East. I would think to place it wherever J1 is placed - since both are from there, and I consider their histories intertwined. But, I don't exactly agree with assigning race to a haplogroup. I also think Hajimurad brings up a valid point. With regard to J2, I know many South and Central Asians belong to the haplogroup - which make it more difficult to make classifications such as this.

[The Sun King]

N1 - white of snow

Lol. Slightly asiantic

[The Sun King]

It depends on what you define as "white".

I belong to J2a, which originated in the Middle East. I would think to place it wherever J1 is placed - since both are from there, and I consider their histories intertwined. But, I don't exactly agree with assigning race to a haplogroup. I also think Hajimurad brings up a valid point. With regard to J2, I know many South and Central Asians belong to the haplogroup - which make it more difficult to make classifications such as this.

I understand they are intertwined but J1 has a too high a semetic component to be considered white. This is up for debate though as some subclades I suppose can be considered European.