Rabbi's call for removal of Church at Auschwitz

[Creoda]

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-h...source=twitter

OSWIECIM, Poland (Reuters) - Four U.S. rabbis led by New York’s Avi Weiss gathered on Sunday in front of a church next to the Nazi German death camp at Birkenau in Poland arguing for its removal from a site where more than a million Jews were murdered.

Rabbi Jonathan Leener, Rabbi Ezra Seligsohn, Avi Weiss, Rabbi Shabbos Kestenbaum hold banners as they attend a protest to move a church situated next to Birkenau, former German Nazi death camp in Brzezinka near Oswiecim, Poland January 26, 2020. REUTERS/Kacper Pempel
World leaders will gather on Monday at Birkenau and the nearby Auschwitz camp to mark the 75th anniversary of their liberation.

“This protest for us is very much part of the commemoration. For there to be a commemoration ceremony without an expression of deep, deep outrage that the church is still here would send a message that we’re ok with this,” Weiss said.

The rabbis argue the church should not be on the site of one of the largest Jewish cemeteries in the world and it violates a 1987 agreement between European cardinals and Jewish leaders that there will not be any permanent Catholic place of worship on the site of the Auschwitz or Birkenau camps.

“This (the church) in my mind is the greatest desecration of the history of the Holocaust,” Weiss said.

“Beneath this ground is a cemetery ... their bloods are crying out from the ground demanding justice.”

The rabbis want the church to be moved elsewhere in Oswiecim.

Weiss was making his first visit to the church since 1995, when at the 50th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz he was arrested for orchestrating a sit-in in to protest against what he sees as attempts to portray it as a place mainly of Christian martyrdom.

On Sunday, as mass ended, the rabbis tried to enter the church and speak with some of the parishioners, as well as with the priest. The priest turned away from them. He did not want to speak with them and slammed the door.

Some parishioners raised their voices and expressed displeasure at the rabbis’ presence but didn’t want to speak to Reuters.

Weiss led a long and ultimately successful campaign in the 1980s to secure the removal of a Carmelite convent from outside the Auschwitz grounds. It had been set up in a building just outside the wire once used as a store for poison gas.

Jews were brought from all over Europe to Auschwitz-Birkenau to be murdered during the war as part of a Nazi genocide campaign in which six million perished. Tens of thousands of Catholic Poles, including priests and resistance fighters, were tortured and killed there too.

[The Lawspeaker]

You give them an inch - and they take a mile. Fuck 'em. In fact: build an even bigger one: the victims were killed by occupiers on Polish soil and Poland is a Catholic country that may commemorate historical events any way it damn well pleases.

[puritan.trad]

As a Jew I think that this a pretty silly complaint on the rabbis’ behalf, but I can understand why some people would be wary of increased Christian development near Auschwitz. There is a tiny minority of people in the area and in Poland overall who seem extremely and unreasonably bent on building crosses and other religious landmarks near Auschwitz. At the most radical end was Kazimierz Świtoń who said he was planting explosives on the crosses to deter anyone from tampering with them. This struck me as reckless, dangerous, un-Christian and unnecessarily provocative to the Jewish population of Poland and to the Polish government.

[Loki]

Disgusting. I hope the Poles don't give in to their insulting demands. This Holocaust stuff has really turned into a huge cult, almost like a religion in itself... along with strong fundamentalism and intolerance. I think people are slowly but surely getting sick to the back tooth of it.

[Loki]

As a Jew I think that this a pretty silly complaint on the rabbis’ behalf, but I can understand why some people would be wary of increased Christian development near Auschwitz. There is a tiny minority of people in the area and in Poland overall who seem extremely and unreasonably bent on building crosses and other religious landmarks near Auschwitz. At the most radical end was Kazimierz Świtoń who said he was planting explosives on the crosses to deter anyone from tampering with them. This struck me as reckless, dangerous, un-Christian and unnecessarily provocative to the Jewish population of Poland and to the Polish government.

Interesting, your profile says Calvinist?

[puritan.trad]

Interesting, your profile says Calvinist?

Oh, I mean ethnically Jewish. I’m a convert to Fundamentalist (Reformed) Protestantism.

[Crn Volk]

How about closing all synagogues in Europe instead

[Loki]

Oh, I mean ethnically Jewish. I’m a convert to Fundamentalist (Reformed) Protestantism.

Very good You're the first of this kind that I meet...

[jingorex]

How about closing all synagogues in Europe instead

You would have better luck closing the synagogues than you would the mosques...

[The Lawspeaker]

You would have better luck closing the synagogues than you would the mosques...

Given the role your favourite people have played in promoting mass immigration and multiculturalism ? Closing the synagogues would be the step we have to take if we want to close down all the mosques.