Are Balkan Slavs Slavicized Romanians?

[Aspar]

I2a & R1a Macedonians = Serbian sperm

E-V13 & J2b & R1b Macedonians = Vlach and Albanian sperm

Deal with it!

It's pointless to explain to internet hilly billy like you that I2a and R1a are not Serbian markers. Most of the Macedonian I2a is I-Z17855 which is not a typical Serb subclade like PH908 and those Z17855 you've got are actually Macedonian sperm...

Deal with it serb!

[vbnetkhio]

It's funny to me when you Serbs use 'we' when you speak about South Slavs. Not to mention that the differences are vast from a South Slavic group to Macedonians for example in both culture and genetics. We don't even look the same.

For example, we Macedonians have our own melos and traditional instruments like 'Gaida' and 'Kaval' but also our traditional dances which are quite different than your Serbian for example.

I am also administrator of our project and can reassure u that there is a big difference in our ethnogenesis as well. For example, there are many subclades among the Macedonians which are basically inexistent among the Serbs. But even those that are shared for example I-Y3120 are mostly with TMRCA of the subclade in question. There are some matches that are closer but are apparently the result of Serbian assimilation of the people from today's South Serbia who are quite different than your real Western Serb.

Maybe it's your unhidden desire to apply your thesis of 'same people' and dreams of greater Serbia but that's not the case. Not to mention that our languages are not really 'the same'...

lol, i had Serbs vs. Romanians in my mind when writing that post. nobody mentioned Macedonians.

[Aspar]

I2a & R1a Macedonians = Serbian sperm

E-V13 & J2b & R1b Macedonians = Vlach and Albanian sperm

Deal with it!

It's pointless to explain to internet hilly billy like you that I2a and R1a are not Serbian markers. Most of the Macedonian I2a is I-Z17855 which is not a typical Serb subclade like PH908 and those Z17855 you've got are actually Macedonian sperm...

Deal with it serb!

[Aspar]

lol, i had Serbs vs. Romanians in my mind when writing that post. nobody mentioned Macedonians.

And who do you had in mind in this post

Romanians are proto-Romanians + local Slavs, South Slavs are Slavs + local Vlachs.

[Jana]

Romanians are more Paleo-Balkan than Slavic on average, with some minor Roman and Turkic contribution.

[vbnetkhio]

But Serbs for example are not more Slavic than Romanians.

Then nobody is half-Slav.

Romanians are usually ~25% Baltic and Serbs are ~30% in eurogenes k13

[Pribislav]

It's pointless to explain to internet hilly billy like you that I2a and R1a are not Serbian markers. Most of the Macedonian I2a is I-Z17855 which is not a typical Serb subclade like PH908 and those Z17855 you've got are actually Macedonian sperm...

Deal with it serb!

Z17855 exist among Serbs from regions which are far away from Macedonia like Dalmatia, Lika, Herzegovina, Bosnia, Vojvodina.

[Jana]

It's pointless to explain to internet hilly billy like you that I2a and R1a are not Serbian markers. Most of the Macedonian I2a is I-Z17855 which is not a typical Serb subclade like PH908 and those Z17855 you've got are actually Macedonian sperm...

Deal with it serb!

Yes, but only Z16983 subclade of PH908 has strong connections with East Germany/Czech Republic, area where White Serbs lived. Vast majority of PH908 subclades have strong connection to Carpathians and area NE of it, which was homeland of White Croats.

https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...tion&p=6511041

[vbnetkhio]

And who do you had in mind in this post

South Slavs. that statement is true for all South Slavic nations.

[Pribislav]

Yes, but only Z16983 subclade of PH908 has strong connections with East Germany/Czech Republic, area where White Serbs lived. Vast majority of PH908 subclades have strong connection to Carpathians and area NE of it, which was homeland of White Croats.

Serbs lived on wider Eurasian space, not only in Lusatia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serbino