Hungarians vs Poles - who has more Germanic admix?

[Satem]

There is numerous German minority in Hungary on the other hand some Polish regions were under German rule for few centuries.
Discuss

[Chris596]

Assuming my heritage, poles have more for sure. But my case may not be as relevant to the whole Hungarian population (I know many people who have german ancestors or even full german names)

[Jana]

Hungarians have more Germanic admixture as a group, because almost every Hungarian has NW European admixture while in Poles there is a great difference from west to east.
West Poles have more Germanic than Hungarians on average, but eastern Poles usually have none.

Hungarians are pretty uniform when it comes to Germanic admixture, from Transdanubia to Transylvania.

[Benyzero]

Hungarians have more Germanic admixture as a group, because almost every Hungarian has NW European admixture while in Poles there is a great difference from west to east.
West Poles have more Germanic than Hungarians on average, but eastern Poles usually have none.

Hungarians are pretty uniform when it comes to Germanic admixture, from Transdanubia to Transylvania.

Do you think there is german admix on the east in hungary?

[Jana]

Do you think there is german admix on the east in hungary?

Yes. It's significant even in Szeklers.

[Benyzero]

Yes. It's significant even in Szeklers.

I know about szeklers, they supposed to have some old admix, but if we talk about old admixture, there suppose to be some in poles too, Iam not sure tho. I think where is that german admixture in hungary is significant is rather the south wester and the northwestern part, where there were some hotspots of german minority in the latest centuries.

[Jana]

I know about szeklers, they supposed to have some old admix, but if we talk about old admixture, there suppose to be some in poles too, Iam not sure tho. I think where is that german admixture in hungary is significant is rather the south wester and the northwestern part, where there were some hotspots of german minority in the latest centuries.

Sorry, I should have said Germanic rather. Most of it is old, from Gepids, Goths and even conqueror tribes, who were mixed with Germanics. Than you had medieval German and Dutch immigrants to towns.
Speaking about recent Swabian admixture, it should be big only in parts of Transdanubia and Banat I think.

[Benyzero]

Sorry, I should have said Germanic rather. Most of it is old, from Gepids, Goths and even conqueror tribes, who were mixed with Germanics. Than you had medieval German and Dutch immigrants to towns.
Speaking about recent Swabian admixture, it should be big only in parts of Transdanubia and Banat I think.

Okay thats fine

[Chris596]

Hungarians have more Germanic admixture as a group, because almost every Hungarian has NW European admixture while in Poles there is a great difference from west to east.
West Poles have more Germanic than Hungarians on average, but eastern Poles usually have none.

Hungarians are pretty uniform when it comes to Germanic admixture, from Transdanubia to Transylvania.

I agree that it's present from Transdanubia to Transylvania. But I'm not sure about the uniformity, sometimes I can clearly tell if someone has significantly more admixture or not

[Blondie]

Hungarians by far:





autosomally hungarians are closer to germans, austrians: