1
Thumbs Up |
Received: 14,015 Given: 6,614 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
What do you mean? Most people in my country belong to R1b. Even your Y-DNA is R1b. There was also R1b in Yamnaya.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 3,748 Given: 9,033 |
They probably influenced IE, also i think they built some groundwork for early IE.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
In the Neolithic time there was a mutual geneflow between Sredny Stog and pre-(non)-IEan Yamnaya and there was a huge geneflow from Yamnaya after it was Indo-Europeanised. Yamnaya just 'kurganized' the late Sredny Stog culture.
It is possible that pre-IEan people from Yamnaya influeced LATE PIEan dialect. That's why there was already a difference between proto-Anatolia and late-IEan Yamnaya dialect. Late IEan Yamnaya dialect was influenced by the Uralic EHG people. There are many studies about that influence.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 14,015 Given: 6,614 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
Yes, but most Europeans came from CWC and BBC at the first place. They didn't came directly from Yamnaya.
CWC was like for about 70% Yamnaya like after Yamnaya expansion, right?
There was either Anatolian Farming hypothesis or Kurgan Steppe hypothesis.
If Sredny Stog was IEan before Yamnaya, then Anatolian Farming hypothesis
But all evidence go toward the Kurgan hypothesis (combination of Steppe/CHG hypothesis).
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
double post
Thumbs Up |
Received: 1,992 Given: 432 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
What is a lie?
Srendy Stog was similar to the pre-Indo-European/pre-kurgan Yamnaya. Before Yamnaya was Indo-Europeanized it was actually pretty related to Srendy Stog. There was a mutual geneflow between Srendy Stog and non-IEan pre-Kurgan Yamnaya Horizon. Like I said earlier, see post #14. Later after Yamnaya Horizon was IEanized and got kurgans from copper age CHG people, it got much more CHG/Iran_Chl like DNA than Srendy Stog.
Yes, West Asiatic CHG, but not CHG of 10000 years ago, but CHG of 6000 years ago. Similar to Iran-ChL.
Srendy Stog had a lot more EEF/ANF, around 20%, maybe much more, I have to see other results. While Late Indo-Europeanized 'Kurgan'-culture Yamnaya had much more copper age CHG/Iran-Chl.
Last edited by Eline; 05-05-2020 at 07:53 PM.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 141 Given: 119 |
The fact is that first there were no 'Kurgans' in Sredny Stog and pre-Indo-Europeanized Yamnaya. Later we see kurgans arriving together with the CHG/Iran_Chl in Yamnaya and from there it was spread into the western parts of the Black Sea.
Kurgans + advanced metallurgy in Yamnaya and much later in Sredny Stog came from West Asia/Caucasus.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks