Classify some Amish Men, have they developed their own phenotype and where can they pass in Europe?

[Tauromachos]

They look mostly like Germans... A few British looks as well. A few look a bit more "southern" even. There is significant Swiss ancestry in them, so I've seen some of them score Italian and French. Usually not much, but still. I am yet to see any Ashkenazi, even in Mennonites, who often have some Eastern European.

Sicilian Amish

[Creoda]

BTW if anyone wants to watch a documentary on the Amish and some of their defectors you can watch this documentary. It also contains some sections of them talking in Pennsylvania Dutch so that’s interesting. It is made by a evangelical Christian group so it might show some bias and mislead you in certain parts especially on their theology but other than that it’s pretty good

I think they did a pretty good job in representing Amish looks in the movie 'Witness' (a few major actors aside), if you've seen it.

[Hoihey]

If you see some youth in normal cloths they’re on rumspringa

[Hoihey]

[Septentrion]

The Amish are completely isolated from the average American gene pool due to their beliefs, they won’t have children with anyone who isn’t Amish (sometimes even anyone who isn’t in their particular Amish group). They speak their own language, have their own schools, church districts, towns, the only time they interact with outsiders is for business. A group of 500 arrived in the U.S in the 1700s from The Palatinate, Germany. Another group of 1500 arrived in the mid 19th century, mostly from the Palatinate and Alsace but also a few from Switzerland. Today there are over 350,000 of them living in the U.S, mostly Germans from the Palatinate, about 25,000 of them are decedents from the group in Switzerland. I realized that as I looked through a few of these photos some of the Amish seemed to look pretty peculiar, as if they had their own “look” about them. What do you think? Do you think that after hundreds of years of isolation these Amish have started to develop their own phenotype?

Western, Central and North - West Europe.

[Hoihey]

[Hoihey]

One thing I’ve noticed is that their noises are long and pointy, without any pumps or hooks

[Hoihey]

[Hoihey]

Null

[Hoihey]

Null