Are Poles just Slavicized?

[Leto]

Your grammar and mannerisms are not that of a native Russian. I interact with two native Russian cousins regularly and there is much difference. You come across as an American in many ways. I bet you are a poser.
This is how one of them types. Broken English and such. I notice your grammar is better than most Americans.

Many thanks. I was very important to know that she is from Sarov

Once again - can you please stop quoting me? I don't want to interact with you. Thank you.

[Loki]

A couple of studies from what I have seen show that Polish people show genetic continuity to the Polish Bronze Age, so does this indicate that Poles are Slavicized? Did a Slavic elite just take over the modern-day area of Poland during the Great Migration Period and Slavicize it through culture, linguistics, and religion?

Studies: http://scienceinpoland.pap.pl/en/node/82059
http://eurogenes.blogspot.com/2019/0...ia-in.html?m=1

Very interesting.

[TheMaestro]

Eastern Poland is core of Slavic DNA, what do you think.

[TheOldNorth]

Central yes, but southern has some submerged German admix, especially in Subcarpathia.

southeastern?

[Loki]

southeastern?

Mosty, yes, because the other areas (west and north) used to be German territory before World War 2.

[Leto]

How small does a genetic influence have to be for a population to be considered '-icised'?

Surely anything over 25%, accompanying language change is effectively a new people created.

So the Jews are not the ones prior to 70 A.D. Genetically mixed, a different language, different food, music and clothing. Hell, even the Talmud and Kabbalah didn't exist back in the day.
Yet no one says they are just "Semiticized".

[JohnJack]

Sorry for my ignorance on this topic but if Poles descended from proto-Slavs near the Ukraine and Belarus border, why would a couple DNA studies show Polish genetic continuity to the Bronze Age populations in Poland?

[The Lawspeaker]

Heim ins Reich !


(Just making fun).

[vbnetkhio]

A couple of studies from what I have seen show that Polish people show genetic continuity to the Polish Bronze Age, so does this indicate that Poles are Slavicized? Did a Slavic elite just take over the modern-day area of Poland during the Great Migration Period and Slavicize it through culture, linguistics, and religion?

Studies: http://scienceinpoland.pap.pl/en/node/82059
http://eurogenes.blogspot.com/2019/0...ia-in.html?m=1

these are just announcements for studies which are yet to come out. And they seem poorly written and probably misinterpreted.

in the first article, genetic continuity of modern and bronze age inhabitants of Poland is mentioned in the title, but it isn't mentioned or further explained anywhere in the text.

in the second article ends with a weird conclusion:

"It seems that we are dealing with an interesting genetic continuation in the population living in Kujawy from the early Middle Ages to the 19th century. The roots of these populations probably reach the Neolithic, perhaps even the Mesolithic" - the scientist suggests.

so they just compared medieval (probably early Slavic) and 19th century Poles, and from this they concluded the Neolithic and Mesolithic population must have been the same? this makes no sense, we have countless other studies showing that there were massive population replacements in all of Europe in the Neolithic and Chalcolitic.

[The Lawspeaker]

Poland ?

You mean: EAST GERMANY !

(the general idea of this thread is so stupid that we should mock it into the ground).