1
Thumbs Up |
Received: 1,249 Given: 524 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 161 Given: 155 |
"I have never seen anyone post dstats or qpAdm results dealing with Baloch vs W Asians that contradicted his results"
The people on AG(not just south asians) seem to be fund of qpAdm themselves and still dont agree with kurd on that regard. If you had a word with them, i think youll find out they wont agree with you(i do assume, as youre about to say, that they have agendas. I DO think they might have agendas, but not on this one. I dont think it sounds right either that kurds and balochs are very identical today).
"Are you saying this based on a large number of verbs and nouns shared between Kurdish and Pashto or are you talking about a Kurdish admixture calculator? Also, I haven't seen any DNA papers out there discussing the migration of Baloch from western Iran."
I didnt meant by language or admixture wise. I meant by he literally said we had proto kurdish ancestry, that the "west asianess" in pashtuns come from "proto-kurds".
ALso, there was this dna plot on iranians from 2019 and the balochs didnt seem exactly identical to the kurds on the plot. Neither most of the south iranians. SOme of the iranian members posted it before. I think you can ask them about it.
"Did that program even have a S. Eurasian component. If it didn't then that's your answer"
I think it did. It def gave west asians such as kurds a lot of east asian, like 8-10%. Im maybe going to post my results(i expected more from his program and the results were less interesting than i thought, just lumping all the west eurasian together)
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks