ADNTRO-New DNA testing company

[JerryS.]

In my opinion the bottom line for people who are regionally mixed such as myself this is a bunch of bunk. If you are more homogenous you will probably get far better results.

[Zoro]

Just because I Had to scratch that itch I sent in my new 23 and me data. The results are a bit off from what I got using my ancestory data. I'm doing this from my phone so bear with me.

Can you post your NW European and your ethnicity match barplot for both your data

[JerryS.]

These?

[JerryS.]

Can you post your NW European and your ethnicity match barplot for both your data

I posted the NW European chart from both like you wanted. I'm waiting for my southern groups to change on the 23/me data. The Ancestry data changed from bulk Italian to bulk Iberian. I wonder what if any changes will occur with the 23/me data? still with the high number they are giving me for Scandinavia and Eastern Europe you'd think they could say Norway and Poland or something.... of course they give me similar number for Southern Europe and have bounced around from one peninsula to the other so far so its just as well.

[Zoro]

I posted the NW European chart from both like you wanted. I'm waiting for my southern groups to change on the 23/me data. The Ancestry data changed from bulk Italian to bulk Iberian. I wonder what if any changes will occur with the 23/me data? still with the high number they are giving me for Scandinavia and Eastern Europe you'd think they could say Norway and Poland or something.... of course they give me similar number for Southern Europe and have bounced around from one peninsula to the other so far so its just as well.

This is what you posted so far. I didn't see the Asian breakdown for V5. Can you post that

Also can you confirm the table is correct

Also Americans are mixed Europeans do you have any idea what parts of Europe your ancestors are from

Population	AncestryDNA	23andMe V5
NW European	68.0%	53.6%
British	17.6%	36.4%
French & German	36.4%	8.7%
Scandinavian	14.1%	8.1%
S European	15.0%	22.9%
E Balkan	0.0%	11.5%
Iberian	12.5%	9.4%
Italian	0.0%	2.0%
Greek & W Balkan	2.5%	0.0%
C & E European	12.1%	17.3%
N African	0.0%	0.9%
SSA	0.0%	0.6%
W Asian	3.3%
C Asian	1.6%
S Asian	0.0%
Siberian	0.0%

[JerryS.]

23,me Asian table.

[JerryS.]

Some Original Ancestry tables. See how the British Irish western French north Iberian table has been renamed....

[JerryS.]

This is what you posted so far. I didn't see the Asian breakdown for V5. Can you post that

Also can you confirm the table is correct

Also Americans are mixed Europeans do you have any idea what parts of Europe your ancestors are from

Yes, I have confirmed paper trails of Scottish (Scotch-Irish) North German, colonial American English, and South Italian. There is suspect North Italian based solely on a surname that could be misspelled. This calculator needs some work. The bulk Italian I initially had was later changed to Iberian as you can see here. Also the complete absence of east Balkan in one and a large amount later assigned.

[Zoro]

Yes, I have confirmed paper trails of Scottish (Scotch-Irish) North German, colonial American English, and South Italian. There is suspect North Italian based solely on a surname that could be misspelled. This calculator needs some work. The bulk Italian I initially had was later changed to Iberian as you can see here. Also the complete absence of east Balkan in one and a large amount later assigned.

This is based on what you posted. Can you also post "Your ancestors in current countries" also for both Ancestrydna and 23andme.

Population	AncestryDNA	23andMe V5
NW European	68.0%	53.6%
British	17.6%	36.4%
French & German	36.4%	8.7%
Scandinavian	14.1%	8.1%
S European	15.0%	22.9%
E Balkan	0.0%	11.5%
Iberian	12.5%	9.4%
Italian	0.0%	2.0%
Greek & W Balkan	2.5%	0.0%
C & E European	12.1%	17.3%
N African	0.0%	0.9%
SSA	0.0%	0.6%
W Asian	3.3%	2.5%
C Asian	1.6%	1.3%
S Asian	0.0%	1.0%
Siberian	0.0%	0.0%

[JerryS.]

This is based on what you posted. Can you also post "Your ancestors in current countries" also for both Ancestrydna and 23andme.

Population	AncestryDNA	23andMe V5
NW European	68.0%	53.6%
British	17.6%	36.4%
French & German	36.4%	8.7%
Scandinavian	14.1%	8.1%
S European	15.0%	22.9%
E Balkan	0.0%	11.5%
Iberian	12.5%	9.4%
Italian	0.0%	2.0%
Greek & W Balkan	2.5%	0.0%
C & E European	12.1%	17.3%
N African	0.0%	0.9%
SSA	0.0%	0.6%
W Asian	3.3%	2.5%
C Asian	1.6%	1.3%
S Asian	0.0%	1.0%
Siberian	0.0%	0.0%

I don't understand what you're trying to get at my ancestors living in Timbuktu or Katmandu have no bearing on anything really. The majority of my ancestors, including me, live in the United States but their map doesn't show anything from here. Also do you have a guess as to why the ancestory data showed bulk Italian that got changed to bulk Iberian? And why Ancestry data shows absolutely no east Balkan but 23.me shows it significantly? No other Data that I produce for you from these 2 readings is going to change my opinion nor anyone else's that this company or its calculating methods need some work. Someone initially made a comment about how the German sample includes a lot of Baltic and Slavic traces. For me that's not gonna work because my German comes from close to the Dutch border actually I think it is on the Dutch border it's lower saxony I have no other information about my German ancestry coming from anywhere else but lower saxony Bremen to be specific. So I think the German sample is not gonna be very good. Clearly it's mixed in with French for some reason am I English and Scottish which should account for at the very minimum 50% of my ancestor I only shows up as 17% give or take. I have no recent scandinavian ancestory so maybe this is just going way back to when maybe my Scottish or English ancestors over a 1000 years ago maybe had scandinavian ancestry I don't know. My Southern ancestry is all over the mediterranean from these 2 calculations. I will admit that the 23 and me values did show the North African that I normally get and the East African that I occasion only get if that sub Sahara is Somalia.