Would you accept your nation losing its "race" to Germans, if they preserved your language

[Harald Meller]

I got inspired by Tooting Carmen's thread:

https://www.theapricity.com/forum/sh...=1#post6857643

Let's imagine your own white European ethnicity becomes infertile.

Would you accept your people getting replaced by German immigrants IF these German immigrants adopted your language and culture?

For example, let's say all white French people become infertile.

Would they be happy about France becoming populated predominantly by Germans, IF these Germans agreed to learn French language?

Or would they rather turn France into a desert with no people or give France away to some other ethnicity that would change its culture?

[Harald Meller]

Basically like Germans in the USA, they melted into the Anglo culture/language, even though they outnumber actual Anglos:

[pulstar]

No

[sean]

Would you accept your people getting replaced by German immigrants IF these German immigrants adopted your language and culture? Basically like Germans in the USA, they melted into the Anglo culture/language, even though they outnumber actual Anglos.

Wrong. You're looking at self-identified origins.

America is still more British than German. "American ancestry" is British. British (English, Scottish, Welsh, Scots-Irish) make up by FAR the biggest ethnic group in the US, people who are mostly old-stock (meaning mostly British) are more likely to simply identify with the only immigrants they knew. Maybe they're only a quarter German, but because the non-German has been American for over 300 years, they call themselves German.

Most Americans have very little understanding of their history, and thus they don't self-identify as being British in origin. Most Americans that have just one recent immigrant ancestor will end up self-identifying as that rather than actually looking back in their family tree.

Go watch any Ancestry DNA result video on YouTube and look at how many Americans think they're going to be native American and German, and end up being mostly British or Irish.

Will now have your original question answered, majority of white Americans (irrespective of religion) said no during the 1930s simply because they actually opened up their borders to all of Europe from 1880-1920 and that went badly because of Eastern and Southern Europeans.

[Immanenz]

another Harald Meller masterpiece.

[Blondie]

Basically like Germans in the USA, they melted into the Anglo culture/language, even though they outnumber actual Anglos:

These german areas are sparsely populated, unlike the East Coast. I think the average white american is 50% british, 25% german and 25% other for example italian, spanish, slavic, scandinavian.

[Grace O'Malley]

I think Germans need to preserve themselves. I don't think they are going to populate anywhere else if they can't maintain a majority in their native land. Anyway language isn't the most important factor but genetics. A majority German population in Italy speaking Italian would not make them Italians. Italy would not be Italian without ethnic Italians. Would China be China if you replaced them with Indian speaking Chinese?

[alnortedelsur]

No, I want Spain to remain mostly ethnic Spanish for ever and ever. I am not that strict like Cristiano Viejo, and would tolerate some white and Euromestizo Latin Americans, some non Spanish Europeans (in limited numbers) and some few Chinese in limited numbers (it's cool to have some authentic Chinese restaurants, ran by Chinese ) but Spain should remain mostly ethnic Spanish by a large margin. If they have low fertility rates, something must be done to fix it, but not replacing them

In the case of Venezuela I would accept any Europeans in large numbers (but with more preference to Italians and Iberians) to give my native country more European blood (it needs it).

[PaleoEuropean]

Basically like Germans in the USA, they melted into the Anglo culture/language, even though they outnumber actual Anglos:

Germans make up less than 20% of the white population . There are only 40 million German descendants in America.