Why Germans and Scandinavians dont have the same major Y haplogroup?

[Tenma de Pegasus]

In general people tend to think they are descendants of very similar barbarian tribes, I dont understand why they dont have the same male ancestry. Scandinavians(finns excluded) are mostly I1 when Germany is a confusion of R1b with R1a with I and others...

[Ülev]

I believe it's magic

[CordedWhelp]

Different Germanic branches (Scandinavian, Ingvaeonic, Irmionic and Istvaeonic), I reckon absorbed different substrates.

[Dandelion]

Cuckery. In Rethel's Poland women of all ethnicities are welcome, but only R1-men.

[Ethel]

they're right in the middle of the european "peninsula" where R1a and R1b meet, and I1 was assimilated

[Lemminkäinen]

I believe it's magic

Not magic. South Swedes are mostly R1b and West Finns I1.

[Lemminkäinen]

they're right in the middle of the european "peninsula" where R1a and R1b meet, and I1 was assimilated

I1 men were lost German Tribes, like Diutisc, Jutes etc. Finns and Sveas survived.

[Rethel]

Scandinavians(finns excluded) are mostly I1

It is obviously a bullshit.
Scandinavians are in majority R1, picking in Norway to almost 60%.

[renaissance12]

When germanic tribes moved to Germany .. they mixed heavily with local CELTIC PEOPLE and in the alps germanic mixed heavily with non indoeuropean people like raethi in Switzerland Austria and Bavaria and Romans..

[Blondie]

Because germans are celto-germanic, scandinavians are much closer to proto-germanic peoples.