0
Thumbs Up |
Received: 8,490 Given: 10,741 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 15,666 Given: 13,081 |
A haplogroup often tells very little about a person's genetic makeup, especially in Europe (but not only). It cannot automatically tell you how one looks. Furthermore, haplogroups have various subclades - certain clade dominates one region and another one could prevail elsewhere.
Haplogroups are more important when we compare nations by the strength of respective ''ingredient'' there, not when we speak about individuals.
After not shaving for a while:
Thumbs Up |
Received: 10,009 Given: 12,238 |
This was maybe true many thousands of years ago, but if applied to today, then nope. This can be misleading to some people.
In reality there are much more dark colored R-people than I-people. Colonized dark skinned people in Americas have lots of R1 (mainly R1b), not to mention Asian groups like Indians, Gypsies etc.
So in 2020 avarage R1 haplogroup carrier is darker than avarage I carrier and if R1 carriers were morphed into one person, he wouldn't like that blond viking guy.
These are just correlations though, not cause and effect relationship.
Last edited by Universe; 02-24-2021 at 12:09 PM.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 17,773 Given: 1,799 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 8,490 Given: 10,741 |
How many times are you going to discover America? In this thread you did it couple of times.
When you finally understand, that it was allready discovered, especially, when you comment
the info about discovering by proclaiming that now it is you who discovered her truely?
Or maybe you have problem with understanding, and didn't get, that you deny things which
are not written, either maybe you think that all people here a total retards, and could think,
that some 140 mln people in Europe are still black pure bichon types since ever? Really?
Last edited by Rethel; 02-26-2021 at 07:23 AM.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 5,428 Given: 5,274 |
[QUOTE=Luso;7123324]R-Z225 look like Gypsies.
But... in seriousness:
Hahaha, the guy actually looks like my father.
Thumbs Up |
Received: 25,622 Given: 21,626 |
Thumbs Up |
Received: 10,009 Given: 12,238 |
I didn't claim to discover anything new. When I was reading LostSoul's post I got the impression she's totally new to this and doesn't understand how these things work (because she said "R1a makes people blond and e1b makes people look semitic"). If that wasn't the case I would like to apologize to LostSoul.
My posts were educative and they weren't even addressed to you, but to the thread starter - I was trying to help her. In my second post I was technically quoting you, but it was still addressed to the TS, because saying "I people are black" can be very misleading to newbies like her, when in reality R1a and R1b are more common among non-white, dark skinned people than haplo I.She just wanted to see what people with certain haplogroups look like. Your post about I-people being dark would've made sense if her question had been "How did people like look with particular hg in 5000 BC?", but that wasn't her question.
Can't you see she's new? And she also didn't ask about Europe specifically. And no, I didn't think "all people here a total retards", but it is a thread created by LostStoul who's a new user and eager to learn. She asked a question, and I was specifically replying to her. I wouldn't have said these things had she not opened this thread. What I said was factually correct and not addressed to you, but to someone else. So why are you angry?either maybe you think that all people here a total retards, and could think,
that some 140 mln people in Europe are still black pure bichon types since ever? Really?
Last edited by Universe; 02-27-2021 at 08:27 AM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks