0
Haplogroup R1a is generally associated with the dispersal of Indo-germanic languages. But what are the odds that the Indo-germanic language family comes solely from R1a-M420 rather than originating at the root of R1? Apparently, this solves some of the problems but it creates some new at the same time.
Specifically, it helps explain the genetic background of Tocharians who came to be 92% R1a with 0% R1b, while speaking a centum language, although there is a thousand years interval between the Tarim mummies samples and the first documented Tocharian texts. It is consistent with many eastern Indo-germanic branches having unique R1a subclades like the Balto-Slavic, Indo-Iranic and certain ancient Balkan languages like Illyrian, Thracian and Dacian. Also, it necessitates modern Albanian being the descendant of the Illyrian language or a Dacian language that moved southwestern. Further, it sheds some light regarding the linguistic ancestors of divergent R1a subclades. Finally, it may nail better the timeframe since R1a is estimated around 22,000-25,000 years BCE with R1b estimated at around 18,000 years BCE, while R1 is much earlier.
However, it cannot explain the general absence of R1a subclades from western and southern Europe where Romance languages are mostly spoken, as well as from various Balkan and Middle-Eastern Indo-germanic languages. It is possible regardless that R1b carriers had been more time in Europe and had their own languages and later converged to Indo-germanic languages mainly of the centum type. In other words, adopting heavy type languages while retaining some softer linguistic aspects of their own, but with the lack thereof adequate R1a subclades. Particularly in the case of Romance languages we would then have to settle with an initial acquisition of the language in the area north of the Alps by R-M458 and the subsequent dispersal within southwestern Europe by the Romans. In the Balkans, the presence of R-L260 and R-L1029 in certain regions could explain however at some degree latin varieties like Istro-Romanian or Vlach.
R1a-tree
R1a Indo-germanic languages
- R1a-YP1272 Dacian and Illyrian languages
- R1a-YP1051 Thracian language
- R1a-L664 Celtic languages
- R1a-Z284 Germanic languages
- R1a-Z92 Baltic languages
- R1a-CTS1211 Slavic languages
- R1a-M458 Romance languages?
- R1a-L657 Indo-Aryan languages
- R1a-Z2124 Iranic languages
c5ef253f3fda.jpg
Bookmarks