Are iberians closer to British Isles Celtic people or Italians?

[Sasaolo68]

Italians by far.

[Sasaolo68]

Both iberians and british isles folk (like irish or welsh) share the atlantid and cro-magnoid component (as well as celtic megalithic culture in pre-roman era), which is usually absent in italians, especially south italians atleast.

Nonsense, there are many CM and Atlanto-meds in Southern Italians...

[HectorOfTroy]

Nonsense, there are many CM and Atlanto-meds in Southern Italians...

i was thinking of stallone-oids ig

[Sasaolo68]

i was thinking of stallone-oids ig

Stallone isn't even full-italian, he is half Ashkenazi Jewish and French + Southern Italian from Apulia.

[HectorOfTroy]

Stallone isn't even full-italian, he is half Ashkenazi Jewish and French + Southern Italian from Apulia.

southern italians have considerable MENA influence on average

[Sasaolo68]

southern italians have considerable MENA influence on average

So what? They still have some cromagnoid, even North Africans share some Southern Cro Magnoid component. Just accept it LMAO, Iberians are mostly Mediterranean, hands down, you have no reason to be ashamed of that and claim that you are closer to "cELtiC".

Yes, Iberians are more Northern shifted than Southern Italians, but they still have more North African in Iberia than in Southern Italy, so, yes, Iberians have some MENA in them, just like the Southern Italians, plus CM and Atlantids in Southern Italians AREN'T absent, now quit trolling...

[Avgvstvs]

Yes the South French are the closest but the question was if Italians or British Isles (Celts) were closer. I think people looking at genetics for a while now know that the Celtic thing is very overblown because populations are mixed at any rate (or not very mixed as in similar to the Bronze Age populations) and also were the Celts even one genetic entity? Lots of unknowns and it would be an interesting discussion.

Celtic is linguistical and cultural term, like Semitic is.

Inviato dal mio SM-A405FN utilizzando Tapatalk

[Avgvstvs]

So what? They still have some cromagnoid, even North Africans share some Southern Cro Magnoid component. Just accept it LMAO, Iberians are mostly Mediterranean, hands down, you have no reason to be ashamed of that and claim that you are closer to "cELtiC".

Yes, Iberians are more Northern shifted than Southern Italians, but they still have more North African in Iberia than in Southern Italy, so, yes, Iberians have some MENA in them, just like the Southern Italians, plus CM and Atlantids in Southern Italians AREN'T absent, now quit trolling...

Atlantic Facade stronger than ever🫂

Inviato dal mio SM-A405FN utilizzando Tapatalk

[Grace O'Malley]

Celtic is linguistical and cultural term, like Semitic is.

Inviato dal mio SM-A405FN utilizzando Tapatalk

Yes now it is and it is possible that there never was a genetic Celtic population because the Romans called many disperse tribes Celtic. I just don't know and hopefully genetic studies will be published with more genomes in the future. I'm as confused as I ever was about the Celts. I'd be happy to go along with whatever the studies say. I think the Gauls have a good claim on the Celtic homeland. I just call Irish Gaels instead of the more inclusive Celtic name because Gaels is factual and also just includes the Irish, Manx, and some Scots.

[Sasaolo68]

Atlantic Facade stronger than ever🫂

Inviato dal mio SM-A405FN utilizzando Tapatalk

According to him, paleo-atlantid and atlantid are the most common phenotype found in Iberians. At least Atlanto-Med it is common in Iberia but not Atlantid LOL.