Are Kurds more closer to the Caucasus people or Iranians?

[Avicenna]

Wtf. You liked the IBS showing Caucasians closest to Kurds yet you don’t like the part showing Kurds closest to Pashtuns and Brahui ! You can’t selectively like one part because it fits your preconceived notion and reject the other because it doesn’t. You either have to like the whole the thing or reject the whole the thing and if you reject it the burden is on you to show that you ran it with exactly the same data using the same SNPs and got different results.

It’s really not difficult to run IBS. If I can do it anyone can

Lol that's what happens when insincere people with a hidden agenda act. Its okay for Kurds to be close to Caucasians , yayy everything is fine and dandy, but the minute pashtuns show up its end of the world and the calculator should be buried six feet under lol. You are absolutely correct, the burden of proof is on him to show your method is invalid. I doubt he even understands what it shows let alone disprove it!

[Avicenna]

Wtf. You liked the IBS showing Caucasians closest to Kurds yet you don’t like the part showing Kurds closest to Pashtuns and Brahui ! You can’t selectively like one part because it fits your preconceived notion and reject the other because it doesn’t. You either have to like the whole the thing or reject the whole the thing and if you reject it the burden is on you to show that you ran it with exactly the same data using the same SNPs and got different results.

It’s really not difficult to run IBS. If I can do it anyone can

Lol that's what happens when insincere people with a hidden agenda act. Its okay for Kurds to be close to Caucasians , yayy everything is fine and dandy, but the minute pashtuns show up its end of the world and the calculator should be buried six feet under lol. You are absolutely correct, the burden of proof is on him to show your method is invalid. I doubt he even understands what it shows let alone disprove it!

[Babak]

Your basing it on autosmal.calculators . According to dstats IBD and IBS they seem to be pop up high on each others population list . People need to stop dividing iranics when there is more variation among Arabs , or Indians, or Europeans .

Wait, so there isnt a genetic divide between Iranics?

[Avicenna]

Wait, so there isnt a genetic divide between Iranics?

It is, but js immensely exaggerated . They are divided just as there is a divide between Italians and spanirads, Germans and Swedes , Moroccans and Tunisians .

[Babak]

It is, but js immensely exaggerated . They are divided just as there is a divide between Italians and spanirads, Germans and Swedes , Moroccans and Tunisians .

Oh ok, I see.

[Avicenna]

Wait, so there isnt a genetic divide between Iranics?

It is, but js immensely exaggerated . They are divided just as there is a divide between Italians and spanirads, Germans and Swedes , Moroccans and Tunisians .

[Avicenna]

Wait, so there isnt a genetic divide between Iranics?

It is, but js immensely exaggerated . They are divided just as there is a divide between Italians and spanirads, Germans and Swedes , Moroccans and Tunisians .

[Babak]

It is, but js immensely exaggerated . They are divided just as there is a divide between Italians and spanirads, Germans and Swedes , Moroccans and Tunisians .

Lol triple post

[Zoro]

Lol that's what happens when insincere people with a hidden agenda act. Its okay for Kurds to be close to Caucasians , yayy everything is fine and dandy, but the minute pashtuns show up its end of the world and the calculator should be buried six feet under lol. You are absolutely correct, the burden of proof is on him to show your method is invalid. I doubt he even understands what it shows let alone disprove it!

But my point is if the method is if IBS is invalid it should affect Kurd results also not just Pashtun results because it’s the same dataset and same SNPs.

I even explained that the reason we see Caucasians such as Azeris, Lezgins, Balkar, Kumyk, Georgians, Armenians closest to Kurds while IBS using whole genomes shows Kurds closest to many Brahui and Baloch and Pashtun is the same example as Britain is closest to Iceland while the opposite is not true and France, Belgium, Netherlands closest to Britain

What will cause this type of result is if the common ancestors of Kurd, Brahui, Baloch and Pashtun split and one part (kurds settle in NW Iran) while other part (Pashtun, Brahui, Baloch settle in E. Iran

[placebo]

Iranic groups but most similar Armenians imo.