Known Ancestry vs Midpoint Plotting: Should one identify with a genetic midpoint?

[Thracian]

Both can be inaccurate.

That also be totally awkward if someone who has half Greek and half Ukrainian ancestry claims he is a Serb.

Some of our known ancestors could also have been assimilated and adopted new society with new names and religions etc...

[Karol Klačansky]

Lol, you regularly plot even kind of within my family genetically, so a little more devotion to that, please!

I have no problems with east germans, its u guys who dont care as much for your west slavic brothers.

[kingmob]

The 'homogenous' nation states of 18th-20th century are strictly enlightenment/masonic projects that have outlived the purpose of their original creators, ie the division of the Christian peoples under false premises, and the replacement of Christian tradition and Faith with ridiculous abstract concepts and notions such as "statehood" and the "rule of civil law", "citizenship", etc., all of them luciferian principles in their origin.

Now they mobilize to replace those outdated creations with their new project, the globalized super-state in the service of their master.

The people who adhere to those old 18th-20th century notions of nationhood have yet to understand they adhere to a lie, set up to entrap them in a false premise in the first place.

[Renzi]

Someone who is a mix of Swedish and Italian who doesn't speak French is just a mutt. Someone who is a mix of German, English and Irish or Scots, in the Anglo-Sphere can identify as English or Anglo-Saxon. There is a difference.

I agree, it depends on the whole context. It is not always the same.

It then begs the question, where is the supposed cutoff point where European mixes are "mutts" or "not mutts"? What makes a German, English, Irish, Scots mix not a mutt when Germans don't even plot with the British Isles? It strikes me as arbitrary, non-scientific, and out of personal convenience.

[alnortedelsur]

Double

[alnortedelsur]

From now on I identify as Nortern/Central Italian (based on where I plot on PCA maps).

I will tell my niece (daughter of my sister with a white Murican guy of mostly British stock), that she must identify as French

[Token]

Basing your identity on your position on a PCA plot is beyond retarded.

[rothaer]

I have no problems with east germans, its u guys who dont care as much for your west slavic brothers.

That's just because we rarely come across as convincing compositions as "75% Slovak, 19.5% British Isles, 2.5% German, 1.5% Swiss German, 1.5% French".

[JamesBond007]

According only to you.

Wrong idiot :


As the nineteenth century progressed, immigrants began to arrive from a wider array of sources in Eastern and Southern Europe, eventually forming a majority of the flow. (Easterlin 1982) New England WASP writers of the mid-nineteenth century like Ralph Waldo Emerson, though decrying the rise of the Irish presence, at least contented themselves with the knowledge that they had been spared the 'Black eyes and black drop….the "Europe of Europe".' (Higham [1955] 1986: 65) Likewise, a new generation of writers in the late nineteenth century, like Theodore Roosevelt or Francis Parkman, subscribed to the idea that the Irish and Germans could combine with the English to re-form a new Anglo-Saxon compound akin to the English blend of Saxon and Celt. This would allow the WASP dominant ethnie to restore its congruence with the nation. Assimilation to Protestantism and the English language could thereby lead to a retention of the ethnic boundary in the face of massive migratory transgression. The shift in source countries from the north and west to the south and east of Europe threatened to upset this national vision, as did the potential of large-scale Chinese immigration post-1864

https://www.google.com/url?q=https:/...Rs1efR0Kv6F4oX

[JamesBond007]

Basing your identity on your position on a PCA plot is beyond retarded.

I plot with the English but it is more than that to me I also live in the anglo-sphere and not France or Germany. There are also some English celebrities that have a similar phenotype to mine.