Originally Posted by
KirillMazur
IMHO, this is nonsense.
1. There are not many such families across the country. They will not affect the overall picture of fertility.
2. In the current conditions, migrants from all sorts of -stans will give birth to their brood, having received Russian citizenship. Even now, on the streets you can see women wrapped in rags from head to toe, with a crowd of small children around. Now there will be even more of them. They will not affect the birth rate in the country, but they will completely change the national composition in the country. Everything is like in Europe. Slavs just do not breed in an modern unstable socio-economic environment (in addition to urban conditions). -stan nations breed, while their living standards are still low (not for long).
3. According to personal experience, in childhood there were friends from a large family (9-10 children in total, I don’t remember exactly), I often visited them at home (5 room apartment). It's a little hell, to be honest. I don't think I need to explain why. All who grew up in that family were "vaccinated" against large families for life. ALL from that family now have one, maximum two children (minority).
More than 3-4 children is really too much for normal conditions. Such large families are normal for a spacious estate, so that grandparents and even uncles/aunts live together under one huge roof. It's good, the little ones have fun with each other while different adults are around, there is a lot to learn from them. To some extent close - a communal apartment. And for ordinary urban conditions - 1-3 children, and "vaccination" against large families most likely will not happen.
4. 1 million rubles is not a serious amount for such a case, and, imo, 10 children is too much for such an award, I would reduce the number to five. 10 children is rare even in Nigeria.
Btw, in large families, parents rarely work at all - various benefits from the state are usually enough for a more or less stable life.
In general, our managers are terribly far from the realities of life.
P.S. Under the USSR, when awarding, adopted children were also taken into account. And, the demographics grew, unlike today. Moreover, the first award of a woman with this order took place in the middle of 1944. And it took for the government of the Russian Federation 30 years to begin to realize something.
There is no confidence in tomorrow - there is no long-term planning horizon - there is no sufficient reproduction.
Bookmarks