Cannibalism in Islam

[Laly]

Sure, there has been some censoring of such claims.

I will have a look at that.


Ok. But is your criticism not better directed towards the extremists (Orthodox Islam)?

Orthodox Islam means "mainstream", "classical" Islam, literally the “right faith”. It is the Islam of the highest Sunni institution, that is Al-Azhar. Anyone who is Sunni, that is the great majority of Muslims, claims to be linked to that institutionalised Islam, linked to the four legal schools.

[Dušan]

Cannibalism is permitted according to the Shafii legal school. See the chapter ‘Eatables’ from the very important legal book by Nawawi (XIIIth century), pillar of Islamic fiqh:



https://archive.org/details/minhaj_a...e/480/mode/2up

Can you imagine that?!

By the way, the Shafii legal school is one of the four official Sunni legal schools and the four legal schools consider themselves to be mutually valid.

Terrible and disgusting.

But somehow not surprising for that religion.

[Atlantic Reptilian]

Orthodox Islam means "mainstream", "classical" Islam, literally the “right faith”. It is the Islam of the highest Sunni institution, that is Al-Azhar. Anyone who is Sunni, that is the great majority of Muslims, claims to be linked to that institutionalised Islam, linked to the four legal schools.

Interesting. What are the other "types" of Islam?

[Victor]

"Extremist Islam" is true Islam. Everything else are Islamic heresies and perversions. Muslim people may be ok, the less they follow true Islam teaching. I mean, there's either "good islam" (heretical versions) or real islam, which is labeled as extremist one.

[Atlantic Reptilian]

"Extremist Islam" is true Islam. Everything else are Islamic heresies and perversions. Muslim people may be ok, the less they follow true Islam teaching. I mean, there's either "good islam" (heretical versions) or real islam, which is labeled as extremist one.

But as for these extreme teachings, where did they come from? The ideas are quite bizarre.

[Laly]

Interesting. What are the other "types" of Islam?

Sects such as the Ismaelians, more linked to Shia Islam, have a reading of the Islamic holy Scriptures that is not literal, but allegoric, spiritual. But those are heretics that represent almost nothing.

There used to be, within mainstream Islam, a rationalistic tendency, represented by the Mu’tazila. During a few decades, in the IXth century, they managed to impose a more rationalistic Islam, with the Quran being considered to be created and not uncreated, which changes everything. They gave dignity to human intelligence and brought possibilities for a more enlightened Islam. But it was only a very short episode, the Mu’tazila have been totally ousted by the more traditionalistic Islam.

[Teutone]

Cannibalism is permitted according to the Shafii legal school. See the chapter ‘Eatables’ from the very important legal book by Nawawi (XIIIth century), pillar of Islamic fiqh:



https://archive.org/details/minhaj_a...e/480/mode/2up

Can you imagine that?!

By the way, the Shafii legal school is one of the four official Sunni legal schools and the four legal schools consider themselves to be mutually valid.

Show me any hadith or surah confirming this.

What you do is the equivalent to someone saying polygamy is a christian virtue by using the theology of mormonism.

[Laly]

Show me any hadith or surah confirming this.

What you do is the equivalent to someone saying polygamy is a christian virtue by using the theology of mormonism.

You’re so pathetic as always… Now, you’re trying to convince that it’s something heretic, marginal, like Mormonism is to Christianity, while it is not the same at all, because this is part of the mainstream Islamic teachings, it’s the official teaching of the Shafii legal school, one of the four official Sunni legal schools. Nawawi is a very important authority of the Shafii school.

It’s part of the fiqh, that is the holy law deduced by Muslim jurists from the Quran, the Sunnah or the Sîra. The fiqh makes explicit the norms from the texts above mentioned, so that every aspect of human life would be ruled by Islamic law. Because yes, Islam is a globalising ideology, encompassing every single aspect of human life, until the way to poop.

The fiqh is part of Sunni Islam in a way that is analogous to the way the Tradition, the Magisterium, is part of Catholicism. You can’t brush aside someone like Nawawi, pillar of the Shafii legal school, it’s like brushing aside Thomas Aquinas in Catholicism, for ex.

[HectorOfTroy]

What you do is the equivalent to someone saying polygamy is a christian virtue by using the theology of mormonism.

Mormons aren't christian...
They're crazy cultists who deny who God is and follow a sexually perverted false prophet, just like how the Bible says false prophets will act.

[Teutone]

You’re so pathetic as always… Now, you’re trying to convince that it’s something heretic, marginal, like Mormonism is to Christianity, while it is not the same at all, because this is part of the mainstream Islamic teachings, it’s the official teaching of the Shafii legal school, one of the four official Sunni legal schools. Nawawi is a very important authority of the Shafii school.

It’s part of the fiqh, that is the holy law deduced by Muslim jurists from the Quran, the Sunnah or the Sîra. The fiqh makes explicit the norms from the texts above mentioned, so that every aspect of human life would be ruled by Islamic law. Because yes, Islam is a globalising ideology, encompassing every single aspect of human life, until the way to poop.

The fiqh is part of Sunni Islam in a way that is analogous to the way the Tradition is part of Catholicism. You can’t brush aside someone like Nawawi, pillar of the Shafii legal school, it’s like brushing aside Thomas Aquinas in Catholicism, for ex.

Maybe do not insult me? I have stopped insulting you and kept with it, normally I do not even interact with you.

I asked you to provide me with sunnah or surah this is based on, even the fiqh is based on them.