1
It was basically on this forum and it wasn't as simple as one population being darkened. What irritated me was that people used to have this idea that Irish and Welsh were the "Celts" and the Scots and English were the "Germanics" and with all the stereotypes and connotations that go with that. That was something that was more common in the first few years of this forum. Then they would put some genetic bias on this with Celts coming from different areas in Europe and tying populations together based on some "Celtic" affinity. In actual fact if you look at any genetic plots Isles populations plot together and they are all in Northwestern Europe. The Celtic thing is a bit confused everywhere and I really don't know how "Celtic" populations like the Irish are if meaning in a genetic sense? All I know is that genetically the Isles populations are all in a cluster so this Celtic/Germanic divide is really only cultural and in the end they all have very similar cultures these days. The closest genetic population to the Irish are the Scots. Also there is no Celtic cluster in that all those "Celtic" populations don't cluster with each other. Irish and Southwest Scots cluster together, Eastern Scots and English are closer and English separate the Welsh from the Scots and the Irish. So really there is a lot of shared genetics with Southeast English being closer to the South Dutch and Belgians getting more input from Europe from both Germanics as well as more French like populations.
This is still the best fine scaled plot of Ireland and Britain that has been done so far.
No one is denying that there are people that have darker colouring in any population. I find that interesting also. But the idea of people like the Welsh being particularly darker is an anthrofora myth that some people still state as fact.
Bookmarks