Rare haplogroups for ethnicity.

[kingmob]

R1a is an Indo-European vector, nothing to do with proto-Turkic speakers.

Z93 for your region is specifically Iranic.

[The_Strategist]

Cladefinder has problems with the clades under R-M417, try Morley DNA it would probably give you R-Z283 or R-Z282. https://ytree.morleydna.com/extractFromAutosomal

[The_Strategist]

R1a is an Indo-European vector, nothing to do with proto-Turkic speakers.

Z93 for your region is specifically Iranic.

That is cool. Croats and Serbs have iranian links according to some historians

[Demirkazık]

R1a is an Indo-European vector, nothing to do with proto-Turkic speakers.

Z93 for your region is specifically Iranic.

It has contributed to the formation of Proto-Turkics, there is a reason you don't see R-YP1456 among Indo-Iranian speakers.

Who were the OG Proto-Turkics then N-VL67, Q-L330, J-PH1795 ?

[Demirkazık]

Chose ISOGG tree not the Experimental one, and scroll down a bit so we can see which subclade you fall into.

[kingmob]

It has contributed to the formation of Proto-Turkics, there is a reason you don't see R-YP1456 among Indo-Iranian speakers. Who were the OG Proto-Turkics then N-VL67, Q-L330, J-PH1795 ?

You answered yourself.

R1a being related to Altaic exists only in your fantasies.

[tk'es]

haplogroups have nothing to do with a specific ethnic group


speaking of r1a, there's indeed a high prevalence among altaic and kyrgyz people







likewise r1b





high frequency among turkmens, bashkir and chad peoples

[The_Strategist]

Chose ISOGG tree not the Experimental one, and scroll down a bit so we can see which subclade you fall into.

[Demirkazık]

haplogroups have nothing to do with a specific ethnic group speaking of r1a, there's indeed a high prevalence among altaic and kyrgyz people

Long live brother, at one time the R1a-Z93 may've spoken Proto-Indo-Iranic but it was already a Proto-Yenisaian or Samoyedic speaking when it got absorbed into the Proto-Turkic genepool. If not for that we would encounter good amounts of Indo-European influence especially Proto-Indo-Iranic but we see almost none.
I doubt anyone would argue to the Proto-Turkics getting their R-S23592 related Y-DNA from Cherkaskul, Tagar and Karasuk cultures, these cultures were either Samoyedic or Yeniseic speaking hence the huge amounts of Proto-Turkic borrowings in Proto-Samoyedic.

[Touijer]

My subclade is very rare, usually people get df27 or u152