Whoa re closer relatives to Macedonians, Serbs or Bulgarians?

[El Gre]

I am Ukrainian.

If modern Macedonians aren't related to Alexander then why would they call themselves Macedonian?

Your a Durak.

They named themselves after the region they lived in , not the other way around. Majority of them were illiterate ox pulling slav speaking peasants, if somebody told them they were Martians, they would be calling themselves Martiadonians now.
If a bunch Slavs settled in Sicily today and 1000 years later decided to call themselves Sicilians, it wouldnt mean they are related to Romans.

Have you ever wondered why there are no 'macedonians' outside the geophraphical border of 'macedonia' ???

[El Gre]

What is so different about the supposed Bulgarians in Macedonia and Bulgarians in Bulgaria? Why would one side make up the supposed "false identity" and the other wouldn't? And why did this phenomenon happen only in one region? And why didn't any of the neighbors of Macedonia consider Macedonians as Bulgarians while only Bulgarians did?

More nonsense. Every Greek called them Bulgarians back in those days and we still do today. According to Cvijic the Albanians simply called them 'Slavs' , but i guess some Albanian posters can tell us how thier ancestors called them.

As for the topic of the thread...

Language is definately a Bulgarian Dialect but they seem to have some common culture with the Serbs like celebrating Slava.

[iNird]

More nonsense. Every Greek called them Bulgarians back in those days and we still do today. According to Cvijic the Albanians simply called them 'Slavs' , but i guess some Albanian posters can tell us how thier ancestors called them.

The region where I'm from we called them "bulgars " today we call them Macedonians and/or slavs

[Vojnik]

Your a Durak.

They named themselves after the region they lived in , not the other way around.

Ahh, no, there has evidence of Macedonians considering them selves as such in an ethnic and national sense.

Majority of them were illiterate ox pulling slav speaking peasants, if somebody told them they were Martians, they would be calling themselves Martiadonians now.

Funny joke. I suppose the same applies to you modern Grks, the majority of yous were illiterate, goat fucking, Slav, Turkish, Albanian, Vlach speaking peasants and then someone told yous that yous are related to Socrates and Aristotle. Now that's a funnier joke.

Have you ever wondered why there are no 'macedonians' outside the geophraphical border of 'macedonia' ???

Wrong. Macedonians have settled in places outside geographical Macedonia, for example in Vojvodina, Serbia and Izmir, Turkey. Plus the Diaspora, Australia, US, Germany etc. So i don't understand what you are trying to say.

[Queen B]

I am Ukrainian.

You are as much Ukranian, as I am Norwegian

If modern Macedonians aren't related to Alexander then why would they call themselves Macedonian?

Because they are deluded, they have no history, and they want to create one?
[YOUTUBE]L87a_bJogVo[/YOUTUBE]

Funny joke. I suppose the same applies to you modern Grks, the majority of yous were illiterate, goat fucking, Slav, Turkish, Albanian, Vlach speaking peasants and then someone told yous that yous are related to Socrates and Aristotle. Now that's a funnier joke.

Unlike you, there are countless sources that prove the opossite.

[Dacul]

Well bulgars are not actually bulgars,since bulgars were a turcik tribe and I did not saw any bulgarian with slanted eyes till now.
So the name of Bulgaria came from bulgarians.But they left very few genetic input.
Romanians have more genetic input from cumans (which were altaians),but I do not see Romania called "Cumania".They say romanians have genetic input from cumans,but I never saw a romanian with asiatic eyes till now.
Think most proper name for Bulgaria is Thrakia.

[Onur]

I did not saw any bulgarian with slanted eyes till now. So the name of Bulgaria came from bulgarians.But they left very few genetic input.

Romanians have more genetic input from cumans (which were altaians),but I do not see Romania called "Cumania".They say romanians have genetic input from cumans,but I never saw a romanian with asiatic eyes till now.

There was even more Cumans in Hungary, probably around 15-20% of current Hungarians are the descendants of Cumans and there is no Hungarians with dominantly slanted eyes either. Guess what is the most reasonable explanation of this!!!
Because Cumans themselves had no slanted eyes and they were predominantly Caucasoid but not Mongoloid.

The traces of Cumans are everywhere in Balkans. It`s not possible that their genetic input being lower than 15-20% of total populations of Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary. Same thing is valid for Bulgars too. I don't think the descendants of original Bulgars are less than 15-20% of current Bulgarians.

but I do not see Romania called "Cumania"

Not today but today`s northern Romania and part of Hungary was known as Cumania during the middle ages and it was called as Cumania by the Roman church too. Cumania was an autonomous region of Hungarian kingdom `till 17th century;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cumania

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diocese_of_Cumania

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Cumania

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Cumania

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuns%C3%A1g

[safinator]

Bulgarians with identity crisis

[Duke]

There isnt much difference between Serbs and Bulgarians in a first place, thus neither Macedonians.


Bulgars were Turkic elite that adopted Slavic language they found in "Thrace", if it were šiptar language, they would probably spoke Šiptar language today, but Šiptars nor their language weren't in Europe back then

[safinator]

There isnt much difference between Serbs and Bulgarians in a first place, thus neither Macedonians.


Bulgars were Turkic elite that adopted Slavic language they found in "Thrace", if it were šiptar language, they would probably spoke Šiptar language today, but Šiptars nor their language weren't in Europe back then

One moment.
There isn't much difference between Croats and Serbs neither so that means there's not much difference between Croats and Bulgarians neither.