Are Ashkenazi Jews A Lost East Gothic Tribe?

[Empecinado]

Ashkenazi Jews were simply Jews who mixed with Central and Eastern Europeans, try to trace their origin in a lost tribe of Goths is very stilted. By the way, Visigoths in Hispania fiercely persecuted the Jews, that's the reason why Jews welcomed and helped the Muslim invaders.

[Lábaru]

AngloJew wants to be Goth because He do not like that Jews come from the Middle East.

[Smaug]

AngloJew wants to be Goth because He do not like that Jews come from the Middle East.

This is ridiculous, also, Anglojew is a Zionist, so he necessarily believes that Jews came from the land of Israel.

[Roy]

If Ashkenazis are Goths than it implies that Poles also are ...

[Smaug]

These people only read the title...

The idea supported here is that the European heritage found in Ashkenazi Jews is of Gothic stock, and not that Jews are a pure Germanic people.

[Anglojew]

AngloJew wants to be Goth because He do not like that Jews come from the Middle East.

No where do I deny or seek to deny that Jews came, originally, from the Near East? I seek to explain only the linguistic, cultural and genetic mysteries of the origin of a distinct branch of Jews; Ashkenazim.

The fact is that DNA proves Ashkenazim are around half-Judean (which is pretty amazing considering 2,000 years of exile) but my theory explains the mysteries surrounding the other half as well as the use of a Germanic language.

[Anglojew]

Ashkenazi Jews were simply Jews who mixed with Central and Eastern Europeans, try to trace their origin in a lost tribe of Goths is very stilted. By the way, Visigoths in Hispania fiercely persecuted the Jews, that's the reason why Jews welcomed and helped the Muslim invaders.

This is Eastern Goths.

[Anglojew]

These people only read the title...

The idea supported here is that the European heritage found in Ashkenazi Jews is of Gothic stock, and not that Jews are a pure Germanic people.

Yes, the Spanish are just jealous because, very similar to the High Caste Hindus, they literally have a caste system (casta) in which those who are fairer are at the top yet they find themselves considered as "darkies" by basically every other European nation. Ironically, although there's many actual Germanic counties they think they have a patent on Goths (even though they invaded and occupied North Africa and Italy also).

Jews on the other hand don't claim any sort of racial hierarchy, being tribal rather than "racial".

My theory just explains the "Northern European" component in Ashkenazi Jewish genetics as being Gothic which also explains the use of Yiddish. I think, as stated, there was an amalgam of Judean, Khazar and probably already heavily Slavicised Goths making up the Ashkenazi founding populations;

[Anglojew]

If Ashkenazis are Goths than it implies that Poles also are ...

How? I think they no doubt have Germanic admixture but I don't follow your logic?

[Mortimer]

i dont know. did genetics reveal any such Thing?