Are Ashkenazi Jews A Lost East Gothic Tribe?

[Lábaru]

Then my theory was true, the Ashkenazi are mestizos of Palestinians + German/Slavs.

[Anglojew]

Then my theory was true, the Ashkenazi are mestizos of Palestinians + German/Slavs.

That's like saying you're mestizos of Basques, Romans, Phoenicians, Iberians, Arabs, Berbers, Jews, Moors and Goths but in a way you're correct except obviously Judeans not Palestinians.

[Damião de Góis]

My theory just explains the "Northern European" component in Ashkenazi Jewish genetics as being Gothic which also explains the use of Yiddish. I think, as stated, there was an amalgam of Judean, Khazar and probably already heavily Slavicised Goths making up the Ashkenazi founding populations;

Northern European isn't explained with germanic invasions/admixture, it's likely a much older thing. If you look at that image you'll see many populations also have "northern european", including sephardis, pakistanis or caucasians.

[Anglojew]

Then my theory was true, the Ashkenazi are mestizos of Palestinians + German/Slavs.

i dont know. did genetics reveal any such Thing?

Yes. I think so.

[Lábaru]

That's like saying you're mestizos of Basques, Romans, Phoenicians, Iberians, Arabs, Berbers, Jews, Moors and Goths but in a way you're correct except obviously Judeans not Palestinians.

Iberians/Celts/Basques are very similar, Judeans/Palestinians and North Europeans are very different, as coffee and milk, a exotic mixture.

I guess that is why Ashkenazi Jews are as aliens to the eyes of Europeans.

[Duke]

Jew, and Jewish is religion in first place, like for instance Khazars were Jews, but by religion, they took it to remain neutral, or something like that.


Goths were Arian, I dont mean in Nazi sense, but of Arian Christianity, they were not Jews, also east Goths or Ostrogoths settled in Balkans massivley, it was their final destination, from where they launched attacks on Rome.
I dont see many Jews here

tentoes.gif

[Onur]

Anglojew, you were strictly opposing me when i talked about Khazar jews, so what happened now? Did you start to believe that your zionist master lied to you to justify the existence of their Israeli state in middle-east?


I will repeat what i said here for more than a year;

Ashkenazim in Europe has been born after the dispersion of converted jews due to the destruction of Khazars state. They are ethnically eastern Goths, Turks and various Slavs who has been converted to judaism, basically the people of Eurasia. Also, i don’t believe the existence of middle-eastern jews among them. They must have been intermarried with Sephardis and middle-eastern jews after their dispersion to eastern and central Europe. They were originally not middle-easterner at all.

Goths were Arian, I dont mean in Nazi sense, but of Arian Christianity, they were not Jews, also east Goths or Ostrogoths settled in Balkans massivley, it was their final destination, from where they launched attacks on Rome.

The original homeland of Ostrogoths was Crimea and surroundings but not Balkans. They came to Balkans together with Huns.

Also, not all The Goths left Crimea but some stayed and lived in there.

[Lábaru]

Anglojew, you were strictly opposing me when i talked about Khazar jews, so what happened now? Did you start to believe that your zionist master lied to you to justify the existence of their Israeli state in middle-east?


I will repeat what i said here for more than a year;

Ashkenazim in Europe has been born after the dispersion of converted jews due to the destruction of Khazars state. They are ethnically eastern Goths, Turks and various Slavs who has been converted to judaism, basically the people of Eurasia. Also, i don’t believe the existence of middle-eastern jews among them. They must have been intermarried with Sephardis and middle-eastern jews after their dispersion to eastern and central Europe. They were originally not middle-easterner at all.

Are you saying that Ashkenazi Jews are not true Jews, only religious convert people of differents ethnic groups?

[Duke]

that is crap because most of Jews show genetic link to Middle East, thing is that those who went for Europe mingled, so they look bit more European than middle eastern

[Anglojew]

Northern European isn't explained with germanic invasions/admixture, it's likely a much older thing. If you look at that image you'll see many populations also have "northern european", including sephardis, pakistanis or caucasians.

Sephardim could be explained by Spanish Gothic admixture and Pakistani with the "aryan invasion" theory. It doesn't discount my theory though.