Pan Finno-Ugrism/Uralism

[evon]

Doesn't change the fact that the frequency of R1a1a in these regions was certainly much higher before the russification of those regions, which brought there even “Russian speaking” Mongols.

The russification of Stalin made that, in the heart of a non Russian (but Finno-Ugric and Tatar [a Kypchak or Northwestern Turkic language]) speaking region, one of the largest automotive plants be built and hundreds of thousands of “Russian speakers” be moved to Naberezhnye Chelny, while millions of Hebrews, of rebel Ukrainians, of Germans, of Finno-Ugrics, of Tatars… were moved or deported to Siberia and Kazakhstan.

http://www.michelangelo.cn/download/...-CARL_MAIR.pdf

OK, so you are basically saying that YDNA R1a1a predates the Indo-European expansion? Which of the theories did you mean to debunk in this regard as there are quite a few, the man you should talk to this about is Polako, i will send him your post link over at AFB, lets see if he wants to debate it, as i think he is among the most knowledgeable on R1a matters..

[evon]

Got a reply from Polako on the matter, which for ease sake i will just quote here:

But you should tell him that the only Turkic-speciifc R1a is R1a-Z94, and that's only because Asian nomadic elites of the Altai were infiltrated by neighboring Indo-Europeans during the Iron Age.

http://volgagermanbrit.us/documents/Kim_et_al.pdf

[Proto-Shaman]

OK, so you are basically saying that YDNA R1a1a predates the Indo-European expansion? Which of the theories did you mean to debunk in this regard as there are quite a few, the man you should talk to this about is Polako, i will send him your post link over at AFB, lets see if he wants to debate it, as i think he is among the most knowledgeable on R1a matters..

he answered me in another thread. I'll debate with him about this a few days later...

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/sho...ropeans/page10

[evon]

he answered me in another thread. I'll debate with him about this a few days later...

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/sho...ropeans/page10

I cant see any posts by Polako in that thread?