0
Very nice post, thanks. Very comprehensive.
About Portuguese, Spanish and French. I can speak and write the 3 and I do not agree with you on the ratings you gave for Portuguese.
Until some years ago, in Portugal, at school you would have as typical options: English, French and German. No Spanish for the simple reason that everybody felt they didn't need to learn Spanish because it was a language that we could speak easily, in fact Portuguese and Spanish tend to speak a mix of both known as Portuñol... after the opening of the borders and the understanding of a local Iberian "market" for work, the need to speak properly Spanish arose and nowadays Spanish is the 2nd language more learned at secondary school level, it supplanted the French that almost disappeared. If when I was in secondary school there would be typically 15 classes learning French, 3 learning English and maybe 1 learning German, nowadays we have less kids and 6 classes for English, 5 for Spanish and 1 for French and 1 for German.
The fall of French and the rise of Spanish has 2 reasons. The first one, as I told before, was the assumption that speaking and writing correctly Spanish was paramount and the second one was the discovery of the easiness to learn Spanish, kids like that. Until here we are in accordance and, yes, Spanish is easiest than French, kids know that.
Where I don't agree with you is when you place Portuguese at the same level of difficulty than Spanish. Portuguese is much more like French at the grammar level, it is tortuous with many irregular verbs and a phrase building very similar. My teachers in Spain had some difficulty in correcting my work because, in their opinion, I had a different way to build my phrases, a French way as they said... whatever that means. Portuguese kids have lots of trouble in learning Portuguese, their own language. In fact, it is one of the hardest disciplines at secondary level and the one that gets lower marks in national exams.
I know there are people that do not agree with me, but even if I’m not a linguistic expert, I can compare things as I’m speaker of those languages and facts corroborate my opinion.
Bookmarks