Classifying Y-DNA into races and ethnic groups

[ButlerKing]

Caucasoid Y-DNA




J1 semetic and Caucasus
J2 Semetic, Near eastern, Caucasus

R1b West Europeans
R1a East Europeans, Central Asians, South Asians

I North Europeans
G South Caucasus


Mongoloid

O3 Mongoloid Sino-Tibetan
O1 Mongoloid Austronesians
O2a Mongoloid Austro-Asiatic
O2b Mongoloid Northeast Asian


C3 Mongoloid Mongolic and South Siberian

D1 Mongoloid Tibetan and Tibeto-burmese
D3a Mongoloid Tibetan and Tibeto-burmese

Q Mongoloid Siberian

N Mongoloid north Siberian




Negroid


A Negroid Bantu-African
B Negroid Bantu African
Eb1a Negroid African

[ButlerKing]

Does anyone have a opinion?

[Smeagol]

Can you explain why over a third of Lithuanians have Haplogroup N, when they score no Mongoloid admixture?

[ButlerKing]

Can you explain why over a third of Lithuanians have Haplogroup N, when they score no Mongoloid admixture?

They actually have 0.7% but anyway like I said before mongoloid admixture vanquishes in 7 generations

1 generation 50%
2 generation 25%
3 generation 12.5%
4 generation 6.25%
5 generation 3.12%
6 generation 1.66%
7 generation 0.75%

[Stormer99]

e1b is mostly Berberid

[blogen]

The populations have typical YDNA in continental scale not the races.

[tEhSaint]

Haplogroups would have much more meaning in a world where populations wouldn't move from place to place and wouldn't mix with others. So you just cant categorize like this.

[ButlerKing]

Now here is the question can you explain why Nenets have 75% Mongoloid Y-DNA but with 63% Caucasian maternal DNA and still look full blooded Mongoloid to predominately Mongoloid??? one should expect nenets to look like Caucasoids




Nganasa extremely Mongoloid as hell with only 7% Caucasian maternal DNA but have 95% N, one should expect they look mix or slightly closer to Caucasoid.

[Smeagol]

Now here is the question can you explain why Nenets have 75% Mongoloid Y-DNA but with 63% Caucasian maternal DNA and still look full blooded Mongoloid to predominately Mongoloid??? one should expect nenets to look like Caucasoids




Nganasa extremely Mongoloid as hell with only 7% Caucasian maternal DNA but have 95% N, one should expect they look mix or slightly closer to Caucasoid.

Nenets have significant Caucasoid influence.









By your logic we should expect Finns to look like Mongoloids.

[Stormer99]

Finns are about 1/16 Mongoloid. Still there but not enough to make them nonwhite.