Indo-European origins.

[Siginulfo]

Proofs were shown previously by many knowledgeable scientists and it is confirmed by a genetics too.
I'm not so desperate to try to convince you with sources. If you are so eager to search for an information, you should have learned that your teory is biased.

Until Dienekes lives, he will continue to find proofs on proofs and I'll support him. I will not yield.

[Artek]

I wonder if Protospatha is trolling or he just started to have a rebellion connected with adolescence.

[Siginulfo]

I wonder if Protospatha is trolling or he just started to have a rebellion connected with adolescence.

I'm not like you that believe quickly to what a guy says you, I have a pulse to find that there could be another theory, a right one. R1a Aryan is going to an end.

[Siginulfo]

There are a lot of people with common sense around the net like me, I'm not alone, in primis with Dienekes.

[Artek]

I'm not like you that believe quickly to what a guy says you, I have a pulse to find that there could be another theory, a right one. R1a Aryan is going to an end.

So could you tell me why there is a low frequency of G and J lineages in most IE populations so far? If the G's and J's were a rulers and a warriors connected with spreading IE languages, why they play so insignificant role in almost every modern European ethnicity.

[Albion]

Stop supposing bullshits and show papers instead. Everything points out that R1a isn't IE, the RgVeda in primis.

Look at the map, I see it is in Northern East Asia too, stop making yourself stupid. You know the eastern ending of the culture comprised most of the Turkic and Mongoloid territory.

FFS, now Central Asia is North East Asia just because you say so is it? Mongols and Turks crept into IE territory as they learned horse riding and weaponry from them and refined weapons such as the bow which they'd use against the IEs on the steppes latter on.

[Siginulfo]

So could you tell me why there is a low frequency of G and J lineages in most IE populations so far? If the G's and J's were a rulers and a warriors connected with spreading IE languages, why they play so insignificant role in almost every modern European ethnicity.

You are right. The cause of the modern political troubles in Europe is to be attributed to R1a communists and R1b

[Albion]

One have to have a good imagination to see that Turkics were comprised in Afanasevo culture, isn't it?

Turkics were present in the east of it mainly because the Indo-Europeans expanded in that direction. They acquired their nomadic way of life from contact with the Indo-Europeans - they copied and refined the IE technology in other words.

[Siginulfo]

I've taken a decision: I won't post in this thread anymore. After all, why do I have to make you know the truth? The right thing is that I know the truth, yes, this is enough. Bye all! Good dreams!

[Artek]

You are right. The cause of the modern political troubles in Europe is to be attributed to R1a communists and R1b

Karl Marx, one of the founders of a communism,was a Jew.
He probably carried Neolithic G or J haplogroup.
Not to say that Lavrietnij Beria had similar ancestry.