Were the Gauls of France related to Irish Celts?

[Grace O'Malley]

No it comes from further South.

From R1b.org



L21 evolved from P312, whose highest diversity is found in Tyrol between Italy and Austria. P312 is the sister clade of U106 which also came from the Alps.

As for languages.



Ancient Ligurian is now listed as being either Celtic or Para Celtic with Italic influences.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liguri...uage_(ancient)

The broken link?

Not likely as it doesn't explain the high ANE in places like Ireland and Scotland. This one appears to make a bit more sense.

[Graham]

Did you check to see how close you are to the Bell Beakers Graham?

nah, probably not that close. Jackson could be though. haven't checked anyone. If I were a betting man. Jackson would be close.

[Grace O'Malley]

nah, probably not that close. Jackson could be though. haven't checked anyone. If I were a betting man. Jackson would be close.

Hopefully he'll post his results.

[Italo-Celto-Germanic]

Not likely as it doesn't explain the high ANE in places like Ireland and Scotland. This one appears to make a bit more sense.

Old and oudated map. R1b came from Russian hunther gatheres by the way.

High ANE came from further mixing with Corded Ware and native HGs in Central Europe.

[Hevo]

Not likely as it doesn't explain the high ANE in places like Ireland and Scotland. This one appears to make a bit more sense.

This map created by Eupedia is already debunked by Haak et al 2015. The other map posted by Italo-Celto-Germanic is based on pure speculations and not likely at all.

[Grace O'Malley]

This map created by Eupedia is already debunked by Haak et al 2015. The other map posted by Italo-Celto-Germanic is based on pure speculations and not likely at all.

Thanks Hevo. It would be great to see an updated map.

[Italo-Celto-Germanic]

This map created by Eupedia is already debunked by Haak et al 2015. The other map posted by Italo-Celto-Germanic is based on pure speculations and not likely at all.

Butthurt R1b is butthurt.

You are free to post any academic or even commercial source to disprove that map from R1b.org, but I am sure you won't find any.

[Aodhan]

Northern France maybe

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

So where do we believe R1b originated?

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

Old and oudated map. R1b came from Russian hunther gatheres by the way.

High ANE came from further mixing with Corded Ware and native HGs in Central Europe.

Russian hunter gatherers?