What is the most controversial haplogroup?

[oblivion]

I say its J1 due to people having different agendas, i.e arabs and jews who claim the haplogroup for themselves, people who do not want to be associated with arabs and europify the haplogroup, etc etc... no one seems to agree unanimously on the group...

[Myanthropologies]

Yeah, pretty much the J haplogroups.

And r1a. Some people argue it came from india (lol), and others from Central Asia or Russia.

[XvThomas_LysergicV]

Probably E1b1.

[Sacrificed Ram]

R haplogroups and his possible mongoloid first carries.

[Abdelnour]

E1b1b, so many famous and infamous people having this haplogroup.

I agree with R also. Please explain to me how a lineage from the mountains of Central Asia/Siberia closest to O, P, and Q could have been of Europoid appearance.

[oblivion]

bump

[Linebacker]

E1b,the haplogroup that destroyed man.

[oblivion]

E1b,the haplogroup that destroyed man.

Elaborate..

[Profileid]

E1b1b

The big dick gene

[Linebacker]

Elaborate..

E1b represents the Early Neolithic Expansion and as a whole the Neolithic/Agricultural revolution,when mankind went from strong rogue predator hunter-gatherer that spins the food chain on his pinky finger and kills mammoths with a sharpened stick to a britle,gracilized domesticated farmer who plants food in the ground and sits in one place waiting for it to grow while his body decays.