Indigenous Balkan I2a1 in southern Albania

[Tschaikisten]

I2a1b-Dinaric are the Slavicized populace of Pannonia and Dalmatia.

[Bosniensis]

Pa i vlasi su I2a1b

[Tschaikisten]

Pa i vlasi su I2a1b

Middle ages Vlachs were social group, not national.

[Bosniensis]

Middle ages Vlachs were social group, not national.

Vlachs as a Polish guy explained are Romans.

He said that People from Rome and Italy are called Vlachs.

So if Polish Slavic people called Romans... Vlachs why do you think that Slavs who came in middle ages to
Serbia did not call Romans Vlachs... after all... in 5th century Western Balkans had 50.000 - 100.000 Roman inhabitants.

[Tschaikisten]

Vlachs as a Polish guy explained are Romans.

Middle ages Vlach are different kind of population than Roman citizens.

Even Slavs which migrated to the Balkans in the 7th century were known as Vlach is middle ages.

[Bosniensis]

Middle ages Vlach are different kind of population than Roman citizens.

Even Slavs which migrated to the Balkans in the 7th century were known as Vlach is middle ages.

So do you think that Romanians from Romania are Romans from Serbia?

Genetically, they are not much different from us.

I've scored 1. Romania in most of Gedmatch calculators

[Tschaikisten]

So do you think that Romanians from Romania are Romans from Serbia?

Romanised Slavs from the Carpatians.

[Bosniensis]

Romanised Slavs from the Carpatians.

OK,

I see them mixed with R1a (Russia, Belarus, Ukraine etc..) with I2a1b...

I've taught that R1a are Romanised Slavs while I2a1b = native balkan people.

But it's true I know very little of genetics and such ...

[Laberia]

Middle ages Vlachs were social group, not national.

Apart your scholars who for obvious reasons, can not taken in consideration, can you tell me a serious scholar who support your claim?

[Laberia]

Middle ages Vlach are different kind of population than Roman citizens.

Even Slavs which migrated to the Balkans in the 7th century were known as Vlach is middle ages.

Source?