2


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 2,900/98 Given: 2,616/27 |
R1b is becouse invaders from Asia (in this case R1b people) had sex-orgies with indogenous Basques (which were not R1b) and that is a result from paternal line of mixing.
They keep their language from the mother side (which were not Indo-European)![]()
But father was of Asian origin. So R1a and R1b is the same branch. Asian origin people who didn't look European, like we have a lot of them today. (result of mixing with white people).


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 8,479/720 Given: 10,728/0 |



| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 689/14 Given: 1,372/6 |
now let me clean the mess
the ancestor of e-v13 e-L618 was found in neolithic dalmatia
Impresso pottery Croatia Zemunica Cave [I3948] M 5600-5470 BCE 769991 E1b1b1a1b1 E1b1b1a1b1:CTS3287:14801129A->G; E1b1b1a1b1:CTS5291:16189080T->G; E1b1b1a1b1:CTS5527:16345952A->G; E1b1b1a1b1:CTS7273:17396160C->T; E1b1b1a1b1:L618:15339697T->C; E1b1b1a1b1F2215:8262442A->G; E1b1b1a1b1F2246:22073053G->A; E1b1b1a:CTS8899:18538216C->A; E1b1b1a:L546:17516070C->T; E1b1b1aF2108:7804308C->T; E1b1b1aF2114:8232450C->A; E1b1b1aF2173:21036413C->T; E1b1b1aF2178:21583211C->A; E1b1b1aF2188:22080316G->A; E1b1b1:CTS2216:14221285G->T; E1b1b1:CTS3637:15089380A->G; E1b1b1:CTS6298:16808859A->G; E1b1b1:CTS6834:17138251A->G; E1b1b1:CTS7154:17325559G->T; E1b1b1:CTS9956:19170454C->T; E1b1b1:CTS10184:19316389A->T; E1b1b1:L796:21358197T->C; E1b1b1:M5041:21491115A->G; E1b1b1:M5047:21977569C->T; E1b1b1:M5078:7721674G->A; E1b1b1:M5108:8880108G->A; E1b1b1:M5322:22181731G->A; E1b1b1:M5360:23618826C->T; E1b1b1F1575:9389773T->G; E1b1b1F1619:13848122T->C; E1b1b:CTS225:2827409C->T; E1b1b:CTS8479.1:18045601C->T; E1b1b:CTS9049:18637397C->G; E1b1b:CTS10513:19503700T->C; E1b1b:CTS10679:22700429G->A; E1b1b:CTS11223:23021729G->A; E1b1b:L336:21903853G->A; E1b1b:M5082:7905833C->T; E1b1b:M5083:7906010A->G; E1b1b:M5101:8692771C->T; E1b1b:M5305:21658631G->C; E1b12:21610831G->A; E1:CTS955:7104553C->T; E1:CTS5913:16550700G->A; E1:CTS9083:18662674G->A; E1:CTS9753:19058376G->A; E:CTS860:7052802A->T; E:CTS2893:14545105G->A; etc N1a1 source Mathieson 2017
also avellander cave iberia
Epicardial Spain Avellaner cave, Catalonia [Ave 07] M 5000 BC E1b1b1a1b1a M35.1, V13, Ei in STR table U5 16051G; 16189C; 16270T source :Lacan 2011b
and we have e-m78 in sopot culture
Sopot (proto Lengyel) Hungary Bicske-Galagonyás [BICS 4]
5000-4800 BC E1b1b1a1 M78 H39 16299g Szécsényi-Nagy 2015 thesis
so this hapologroup have been in europe for along long time much before the indo european who came from the steppe
you are correct though that the natufian not belong to e-v13
they belong to e-z830 the ancestor of m123-m34 the middle eastern version of e1b1b1 who descendnents from e-z827
E1b1b1b has been identified among Natufians, and later among Levantine PPNB
Natufian Israel Raqefet Cave, Mount Carmel [I1072 / Nat 9] M 11840-9760 BCE E1b1b1b2 Z830 (xE1b1b1b2a, E1b1b1b2b) CTS8182+, CTS11781+ (E1b1b1b2), (CTS1652-, CTS11051-, CTS11574-) N1b ? source: Lazaridis 2016
Natufian Israel Raqefet Cave, Mount Carmel [I0861 / Nat 10] M 11840-9760 BCE E1b1b1b2 Z830 (xE1b1b1b2a, E1b1b1b2b) L336+ (E1b1b), M5108+, CTS3637+, CTS7154+, PF1755+, L796+ (E1b1b1), CTS11781+ (E1b1b1b2), (L857-, Z865-)
sourece: Lazaridis 2016
hope i clarify a little bit .......


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 4,652/2,004 Given: 658/634 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 8,479/720 Given: 10,728/0 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 4,652/2,004 Given: 658/634 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 8,479/720 Given: 10,728/0 |
Where did I say that I don;t know?
Are you butthurted, that you think that you are from Ethiopia?
In that case you should be butthurted on yourself, not me.
It was your statement, not mine.
And what?MY Y cromosome cousins mainly in Skandinavia, and yours mainly in India Pakistan area, if we go by the absolute numbers.
And what?Deal with it.


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 4,652/2,004 Given: 658/634 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 8,479/720 Given: 10,728/0 |


| Thumbs Up/Down |
| Received: 4,652/2,004 Given: 658/634 |
There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)
Bookmarks