DNA test results of Chris596

[Scandal]

Chris,

Do you have Serb/South Slavic surnames in your family?

[Leto]

I don't think it exaggerates for everyone. I have 9.31% in K12b, have 9.1% in Punt K13

For him (and for me among others) it does. Maybe for you it's okay.

[Impaler]

I don't think it exaggerates for everyone. I have 9.31% in K12b, have 9.1% in Punt K13

Do you count also Amerindian and Oceania?

[vbnetkhio]

Well if the result is not accurate it doesn't matter everyone gets a similar result. On the other hand, I don't think this is the case. Imagine a Serb gets 40% Eastern Euro yet his Balkan part balanced with Greek, not Serb. On the other hand, a Serb gets 20% Eastern Euro because his Balkan part balanced with Bulgarian, Montenegrin etc.. Both have identical results in Gedmatch. So, what caused such a difference in 23andMe? They use IBD after algorithm finds a population to fulfill your breakdown then assigning you regions according to IBD results. Instead, they should measure your relativity before assigning you a component.

This is the problem.




Imagine what I thought after see my own result

With all of my seriousness, I can prepare a better algorithm for everyone if I had their dataset. This actually applies to all companies.

yeah, those are drawbacks. all commercial tests are dumbed down. but 23andme is the least bad.
FTDNA and Ancestry admixtures are too broad and boring, they play it safe. MyHeritage attempts to be more detailed but the components are so badly made that the results are useless.

But in the end they are all just good for the raw data, and Eurogenes K13 is the real deal.

[Kaspias]

Do you count also Amerindian and Oceania?

Oceania yes, Amerindian no.

[Leto]

This is an interesting model

63.1% Bulgarians (Yunusbayev) + 36.9% Hungarians (Behar) @ 2.5

The BG and HU references on Dodecad aren't bad unlike many others.

[PAGANE]

Comparison results of my cousin made at both 23andme and https://www.myheritage.com/dna/ethni...9O78U2AA9T5KTOmyheritage companies



23andme

[Leto]

Oceania yes, Amerindian no.

Oceanian in Europeans is absolutely noise and shouldn't be paid attention to. Unless you're an old stock Aussie or Kiwi of course

[Kaspias]

Comparison results of my cousin made at both 23andme and https://www.myheritage.com/dna/ethni...9O78U2AA9T5KTOmyheritage companies



23andme

PAGANE, can you please post your 23andMe results and your Eurogenes K13?

[Impaler]

Oceania yes, Amerindian no.

I have 4.21% EE. NE_Asia + Siberian + Oceania.


Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 79.3% Bulgarian + 20.7% Afghan_Uzbeki @ 3.11
2 76.1% Macedonian + 23.9% Afghan_Uzbeki @ 3.15
3 81.5% Macedonian + 18.5% Burusho @ 3.54
4 75.9% Romanian + 24.1% Nogay @ 3.54
5 73.8% Romanian + 26.2% Turkish_Aydin @ 3.63
6 81.3% Romanian + 18.7% Afghan_Uzbeki @ 3.63
7 74.6% Macedonian + 25.4% Tadjik @ 3.87
8 84.4% Bulgarian + 15.6% Afghan_Hazara @ 3.93
9 84.6% Bulgarian + 15.4% Burusho @ 3.99
10 58.3% Moldavian + 41.7% Turkish @ 4.02
11 78.4% Bulgarian + 21.6% Tadjik @ 4.04
12 54% Turkish + 46% Utahn_European @ 4.04
13 85.8% Romanian + 14.2% Afghan_Hazara @ 4.04
14 74.7% Bulgarian + 25.3% Nogay @ 4.06
15 61.7% Moldavian + 38.3% Turkish_Kayseri @ 4.07
16 50.5% Turkish_Kayseri + 49.5% Utahn_European @ 4.08
[B]17 52.6% Turkish_Aydin + 47.4% Belgian @ 4.09
18 56.5% Spaniard + 43.5% Tadjik @ 4.11
19 55.7% Turkish_Aydin + 44.3% Utahn_European @ 4.22
20 80.8% Macedonian + 19.2% Pathan @ 4.26